Mitchell's Steakhouse Columbus Downtown

Mitchell's Steakhouse Columbus Downtown

45 North Third StreetOH 43215, Columbus, United States Reservation
4.1 /5
4408 Reviews

"I've been here with my colleagues before, it's a great experience"

Details

Phone: +16146212333

Address: 45 North Third StreetOH 43215, Columbus, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Columbus

Website: https://www.mitchellssteakhouse.com/location/mitchells-steakhouse-columbus-downtown/

Opening hours

Monday: 11:30-16:00 16:00-21:00

Tuesday: 11:30-16:00 16:00-21:00

Wednesday: 11:30-16:00 16:00-21:00

Thursday: 11:30-16:00 16:00-21:00

Friday: 11:30-16:00 16:00-21:30

Saturday: 16:30-21:30

Sunday: 16:30-21:00

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 4408


Address

Show Map

Reviews

DK

2/5

Went for a team holiday dinner on a Tuesday night. There were 7 in our party, and although the place was pretty empty, they wouldn't sit us until more than half showed up. Not a big deal. Most of the group had the prix fixe with the filet mignon . I ordered the French onion soup, sea bass, mac and cheese and the Crème brûlée. From the table, I heard the filet mignon was overcooked for 3 of the 5 of them. My seabass was also a little overcooked but not bad. Not the best seabass I've had. French onion soup was okay. The Mac and cheese was really good, and so was the Crème brûlée. Service also took a really long time. We sat down at 5:15pm and didn't get desert until 8pm. All in all, not a bad...

Aida

1/5

Working in restaurant industry I didn 't know that servers are allowed to have the loose hair during the service. Second, i believe that if you are getting the new wine bottle, the server has to offer new glasses and not making the guest to help her with that. Last one, the meal was sent back to kitchen due to salt issue but i never heard anything from server as matter: We are so sorry, let me change really quick for you or at least offer anything to comp/discount(doesn 't required but would make me a different impact) All in all, ambiance great, food is good, service is horrible.

Carter

1/5

My ribeye was good but not close to great or amazing. The sides all seemed to me to be right on the edge of overly salty. Again good but not great. The meatball starter and the shrimp starter were both excellent. The banana cream pie and chocolate mousse desserts were very good. The chocolate sout cake was giant and was again good a little dry. Our server or the kitchen struggled with getting things correct. Times from order to delivery was very long. 40 minutes from ordering dessert to delivery. Over all we had a good time. We had more than enough time to talk.

Windy

2/5

During our stay in town for Thanksgiving, my family and I chose to dine at Mitchell’s Steakhouse, which was conveniently situated across from our hotel. We were immediately impressed from the moment we stepped inside by the warm welcome from the staff. Our server, Nicole, was exceptional - she attended to all our needs promptly and with a smile. The food was delicious, and we also had a lovely chat with Nicole and some locals. We have no hesitation in awarding them 5 stars - I wholeheartedly recommend this restaurant. Thanksgiving 2023! Book a table now

Casey

2/5

Very nice restaurant $10 valet on a Thursday. Hardly anyone there everyone was very polite and considerate. Expect to pay around $100 per person. I got the filet mignon chopped salad mash potatoes and butter cake and long island ice tea. Portions are decent and I had leftovers. All came out quickly and tasted very good, especially the salad and long island. Medium ordered steak was rare in the middle but seasoned very well.

Nathan

1/5

Wonderful staff, good food. I really enjoyed the spicy lobster appetizer. Would be 5 stars if the restaurant did not use the bike lane for their valet. I am aware that this is a long running practice of this restaurant and they seemingly have the permission of the city to do so, but it's irresponsible and dangerous and shows that the ownership of the restaurant are not committed to making Columbus a better place to live.

Jon

2/5

When dining in an upscale restaurant you expect high quality food. While the food was not bad, it was very average. The steaks I would compare to Texas Roadhouse. The sides were good. Overall for the amount of money one pays you’d expect a better flavor and quality of the menu items.

Mark

2/5

My wife and I had a wonderful date night at this restaurant. It was our first time here and the experience was exceptional. Our server, Rhianna, was absolutely amazing - the best person we have ever met. We will definitely be coming back soon and will ask for her again. Book a table now

Alex

2/5

The steakhouse is excellent, with top-notch service. The sides are served in a family-style manner and the food is absolutely delicious. Convenient parking is available.


Dishes

Roasted Cauliflower Walnut Mint Pesto
Roasted Cauliflower Walnut Mint Pesto

Jumbo Alaskan King Crab Thermidor
Jumbo Alaskan King Crab Thermidor

Brussels Sprouts Applewood Bacon
Brussels Sprouts Applewood Bacon

Green Beans Walnut Brown Butter
Green Beans Walnut Brown Butter

Gerber Farms Stuffed Chicken
Gerber Farms Stuffed Chicken

Sweet Potatoes Maple Butter
Sweet Potatoes Maple Butter

Jalapeño Scalloped Potatoes
Jalapeño Scalloped Potatoes

Cured Meats Artisan Cheeses
Cured Meats Artisan Cheeses

Mitchell's Chop Chop Salad
Mitchell's Chop Chop Salad

Gerber Farms Brick Chicken
Gerber Farms Brick Chicken