Before visiting Napper Tandy’s in Bay Shore, forget all assumptions you may have about Irish Pubs. My wife and I frequent Bay Shore for meals, and although we had passed by Napper Tandy’s many times, we never thought to go in, assuming it was just a loud and rowdy dive bar. How wrong we were! On our visit tonight (3/8/23), we sat at a table in a cozy corner opposite the bar. Our server, Ryan, who also tended the bar, greeted us warmly. We chatted about dining options in Bay Shore and other restaurants we had tried. After swiftly bringing our drinks, Ryan gave us time to peruse the menu (while offering some helpful suggestions). When he returned to take our orders, he assisted us in selecting...
The staff at this restaurant are exceptional individuals who work incredibly hard and show great care, making them a valuable asset to the establishment. While the food at this restaurant is mostly delicious, there are a few items that could use some improvement, such as the grilled cheese sandwich. The sandwich has a strange taste that suggests the use of low-quality ingredients, like stale butter or a dirty grill. In order to make a truly great grilled cheese, it is important to use flavorful cheese, fresh bread with a good texture, and avoid too much crust. The white bread being used lacks flavor and would benefit from being replaced with a more interesting option like Dave's Killer Bread...
Napper Tandy's is a great place to hold a party. We had our high school reunion there. The owner was fantastic, answered our questions, made sure we had an area for our group and came out a few times, as well as the staff to check on us to make sure things were going well. I would highly recommend this place for any event. Thank you, Napper Tandy's, for a great time.
The place is dirty.Also tends to get violent at night. I live nearby and have seen too many young people (clearly badly beaten) taken away in ambulancesFood: 1/5
Book a table now
Bartender made my drink sooo strong. I'm literally hung over. Didn't really vibe their choice in music but overall it was okAtmosphere: 3/5
The private room upstairs for events is beautiful and the staff was helpful and friendly. I would highly recommend this venue for events.
My Favorite Place to Party!! Great Vibes. Great atmosphere!!! Dope place to be if your looking to have a lit Saturday Night
Large bar, big place, lots of tv’s, great space upstairs for private events, cold ? and great food good times ?
Book a table now
Very clean and spacious Irish bar. The upstairs room was just right for the retirement party.Food: 4/5
Food is great. Friendly service and the atmosphere is very nice.
