"Service was excellent, patrons were friendly, and the food was DELICIOUS!!! I had the corn beef cabbage and the Galic Rib Tips?? Amazingly well prepared and tastey!!! Umm good!"
This is probably very boring for Nicholas Anthony's Family Kitchen to receive yet another five stars, but that's what we give it. We hadn't been to this location in several years, not realizing that it had changed ownership. I love BYOBs because you can better pair to your taste to the food you expect to receive. I'll make this short, the food was great, the wait staff was excellent and the space was larger and lighter then I remember it. The space was a bit noisy and could use some noise dampening/absorbing material . So move over Maplewood, Montclair, Verona and the Caldwells, we finally have discovered an excellent restaurant in our backyard.
We recently hosted a private party at Nicholas Anthony's Family Kitchen and had an outstanding experience. Nicholas was an exceptional host—both friendly and professional throughout. He worked closely with us to design a menu that catered to various dietary preferences while staying within our budget. We also appreciated the option to drop off our wine in advance, ensuring it was perfectly chilled upon arrival. A big thank you to our fantastic servers, Alison and Sam, who were attentive and warm with every guest. The food was truly delicious, and everyone left completely satisfied. We look forward to working with Nicholas again in the future!
We recently had a private party at Nicholas Anthony's Family Kitchen. Nicholas was easily the best vendor we dealt with. Throughout the entire process he was friendly and professional. He was willing to work with us on a menu to meet many differentdietary needs and stick within our budget. We were able to drop off the wine ahead of time so that it was chilled and ready whenwe arrived. Shout out to Alison and Sam, our excellent servers, who were attentive and friendly and made our guests feelwelcome. All of the food was tasty and our guests ate quite their fill. We would definitely work with Nicholas again!
Dining at Nicholas Anthony’s Family Kitchen feels just like being in a family kitchen—ideal for a get-together with your PTA group, especially when you have the entire place to yourselves! The food is incredibly delicious, and the staff is amazing. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming! If you’d like, I can share information about the West Orange PTA discount card, which provides savings at local businesses while supporting the West Orange PTA.
Book a table now
This is what it looks like when you go for dinner at Nicholas Anthony?s Family Kitchen with your PTA crew and shut the place down! DELICIOUS meals. FRIENDLY staff. GREAT energy. Ask me about the West Orange PTA Discount card that allows you to getdiscounts from local businesses while raising funds for the West Orange PTA?s!
Nicholas Anthony's Family Kitchen is a fantastic restaurant! We loved dining both inside and outside, and the service and ambiance were excellent. While the zucchini fritters didn’t quite hit the mark, the Tiramisu was truly outstanding! This family-owned spot in WO is a real treasure, and we absolutely adore it!
I?m going to need the bar top to expand. I love sitting there! My 3 plates of food take up a lot of space.Start with the shrimp beeps. The sauce here is so good. It?s really hard to choose what to eat. The staff is very attentive You really feel like your visiting your relatives for dinner.
I?m going to need the bar top to expand. I love sitting there! My 3 plates of food take up a lot of space.Start with the shrimp beeps. The sauce here is so good. It?s really hard to choose what to eat. The staff is very attentive You really feel like yourvisiting your relatives for dinner.
Book a table now
This place is SO great! We?ve sat inside and outside and the service and ambience are fantastic! The zucchini fritter appetizers are unreal. The tiramisu is the best! Family owned gem in WO! We love it!
Service was excellent, patrons were friendly, and the food was DELICIOUS!!! I had the corn beef cabbage and the Galic Rib Tips?? Amazingly well prepared and tastey!!! Umm good!
Blackened Shrimp Cajun Risotto With Bacon
Half Tray Chicken Oreganata (Off Bone)
Guinness Mac & Cheese With Shrimp
Half Tray Mixed Green Salad
Grilled Shrimp & Scallops
