Northeast Oyster Co.

Northeast Oyster Co.

139 Hoyt Ave, 10543, Mamaroneck, US, United States Reservation
4.8 /5
173 Reviews

"The seafood is delicious and Ray is the best!!! Best shrimp cocktail I’ve ever had. Highly recommend."

Details

Phone: +19143625949,+19143043313

Address: 139 Hoyt Ave, 10543, Mamaroneck, US, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Mamaroneck

Opening hours

Wednesday: 15:00-21:00

Thursday: 16:00-21:00

Friday: 15:00-21:00

Saturday: 13:00-21:00

Sunday: 13:00-17:00

Statistics

Dishes: 6

Categories: 5

Reviews: 173


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Alex

2/5

Disappointing. Walked in looking forward to trying a new place. Instead greeted with DONT SIT THERE, those are reserved. Fine. Half the bar is reserved. So everyone sat elbow to elbow, leaving room for the reserved seats. Seems like a spot for regulars only. If you know the owner you 'll be sitting comfortably. Not a friendly atmosphere. The menus are reminiscent elementary school MS Word lists, each printout with different prices and items. The bar could use a little tidying. Very messy, lots of random dusty things. I didn 't like seeing a mess when eating shellfish. The oysters. They were fine. Warmer than I prefer. I didn 't find them to be fresh and amazing. Lots of shells and grit. The...

Joe

4/5

You're about a party of 10 do you have mostly just beer and Brandi. I had a bunch of food the wings were almost like sweet-and-sour Chinese food it was really good. The dumplings were really tasty because they sprinkled some different kinds of seasonings on them which made each winters different. Unfortunately they were overcooked it a little mushy but they were still good. Then there was this purple bun with I guess a burger in it that was really good. I had to Brandy very smooth. We also had a platter of oysters but never made it to our side of the table it's got doubled up before we got any. I should I had some c eggrolls that a lot of people getting me going to try that next time. Oh yea...

Eric

5/5

Went in around 4PM on a Saturday. Empty at the time, but the owner (Ray) welcomed us in. He's a one-man operation and understands what it takes to make customers happy. Limited menu but it's an oyster bar and that's what you are there for. We had three dozen mixed between the two of us. Ray explained them to us and they were very good. We paired them with some great wine and he even gave us a complementary glass of port after our meal. Great oysters, great service and great fun.

Jaime

5/5

Absolutely the best oysters in Westchester, New York. This restaurant has completely spoiled me for oysters anywhere else. I made the mistake of ignoring my instincts and trying oysters at other places around Westchester, which was a big error. Once you taste the oysters here, your standards for oysters will forever change. Book a table now

Joe

4/5

We ordered a platter of oysters, but they never made it to our side of the table—they got snatched up before we could even get a taste! I also heard great things about the egg rolls that many people were raving about, so I’ll definitely try those next time. Overall, I had a great experience and I’ll definitely be back!

John

5/5

Fresh. Fresh. Fresh. Black Sea Bass Ceviche small but rich! Oysters were on point. And the beer works great with the different Oysters. Perfect spot for an Oyster, quick and convenient!

Jess

5/5

Talk about some of the best oysters and shrimp in NY who else can bring a taste of capecod with wellfleet oysters to NY! The service was unreal and the food was ? thanks Ray!

David

5/5

Cool, clean oysters, and great interplay with the owner. Just a nice, unpretentious but sophisticated spot to get an impressive cheese tray Book a table now

Jessica

5/5

The seafood is delicious and Ray is the best!!! Best shrimp cocktail I’ve ever had. Highly recommend.

Jessica

5/5

The seafood is delicious and Ray is the best!!! Best shrimp cocktail I’ve ever had. Highly recommend.


Dishes

Shrimp Cocktail
Shrimp Cocktail

Ceviche
Ceviche

Wings
Wings

Little Neck Clams
Little Neck Clams

Wellfleet Ma
Wellfleet Ma

Pemaquid, Me
Pemaquid, Me