I ordered the chicken cutlet sub, but unfortunately the meat was overcooked and inedible. As a diabetic, I chose some other options and ended up ordering six meals in total, but everything arrived lukewarm and needed reheating. I’m honest about my experience and plan to return in the future. It was also my birthday, and I had traveled nearly two hours to dine here. Overall, we had a good time and most of the other food was decent—just disappointing when it came to my meal! On a positive note, the restaurant was very clean and the staff were extremely courteous.
I ordered a meatball sandwich, and the experience was quite disappointing. The server went into the walk-in freezer to retrieve the meatballs, which she then placed in the microwave. After that, they were put in the lower oven and roasted in a pizza oven. Unfortunately, the quality of the meatballs was lacking even before they went into the microwave. They tasted like the frozen meatballs you might buy from a big-box store. The microwave only made them worse. If I hadn’t been so hungry and pressed for time, I would have tossed that sandwich aside.
My mother and I recently visited The Pelham House of Pizza, a delightful little restaurant with both dine-in and take-out options. We shared a small cheese pizza with a wonderfully crisp crust and the tastiest cheeseburger I’ve ever had outside of my own home! The warm and inviting atmosphere, thanks to Mr. If It's Free, It's Me, made our experience truly memorable. I highly recommend you check out this fantastic place when you're in the area!
This is undoubtedly the BEST FOOD IN NEW ENGLAND. Check out my reviews—I’m a food lover and have eaten at countless restaurants. Pelham House of Pizza is a charming Greek diner with a wide-ranging menu featuring Greek, American, and Italian comfort foods. The staff and owners are EXCEPTIONAL, and every dish is incredibly tasty! Plus, the parking is very convenient. Did I mention that the food is the best in New England?
Book a table now
The lasagna was little more than a few cooked noodles ,sauce and the smallest amount or ricotta you could imagine..The meatballs I got with it were a good size serving but very bland and gritty to the taste..I wouldn't say it's the worst I've had butprobably closer to the same old stuff..The salad that came with it was ok..the price was good..The serving size was good..Theflavor was off..
In today?s environment many folks forget the basics of providing customer service, good customer service that is. The Staff here has not! Thank you all for your fantastic service! You are pleasant on the phone, you don?t make me feel rushed while placing anorder even when insanely busy and simply provide an all around great experience! Thank you!
We ordered chicken fingers with fries for the kids, a Greek salad with chicken, and a steak tip dinner with fries and a salad. The staff was incredibly friendly, and the atmosphere was lovely!
Mayo does not belong on an Italian sub. Despite that, the sub was surprisingly decent. However, putting mayo on an Italian is just wrong. The pizza, as always, is great.
Book a table now
The food was fantastic, and the delivery took just 20 minutes. I will definitely be ordering from Pelham House of Pizza again. Truly impressed!
Amazing food and staff! Pick up orders are always on point and exactly as ordered.
