"Best pizza I've ever had. Personal favorite of chicago style pepperoni, salami, sausage and pesto."
Pizza Pits garlic bread is so delicious, some of the best garlic bread I’ve had. Their marinara sauce is the perfect combination of sweet and savory and one of the only pizza sauces I like in town. Most pizza places make their sauce too sweet, or too savory but this is the perfect middle. The PitStix are good and in my opinion have more garlicky flavor than TopperStix. The pizzas are great, but their ranch is absolutely superior, definitely get a side of ranch with your meal. Their wings and chicken tenders are delicious and they have so many great sauces to choose from. While I am not a fan of Buffalo wings, my boyfriend swears that pizza pit’s Buffalo wings are the best in town.
The stuffed pizza is delicious. My only issue is that they used to offer fantastic French fries at a reasonable price, but my experience yesterday was disappointing. They’ve switched to skinny fries, which were fine but the price was astonishing. I paid $6.50 for a large order, and it wasn't even that large. I've never spent that much on fries before, and I won't be ordering them again. Additionally, they gave me the wrong size pizza. It was still tasty; it just wasn't the size I expected. Overall, the pizza remains good.
This is Hands DOWN….best pizza in Wisconsin, 10 out of 10, the employees are friendly, caring and the chef is second to none, all his pizzas are made with tinder love and care. I have ate there the last 5 days in a row for a reason??? best pizza in Wisconsin and I’m willing to die on that hill I never been hooked on pizza until I ate here.
We visited this restaurant after a field trip with our students. There was only one person working, and the menu had limited options. We could only order slices of pizza, but the staff member was very friendly. I have no complaints about the pizza itself. By the way, they are hiring if anyone is looking for a job!
Book a table now
First off, the super hot buffalo wings were amazing and the workers were super nice. We asked for recommendations on the 2 pizzas we were getting and the suggestions that Travis gave us ended up being the some of the best thin crust we’ve ever had. Will definitely be back and strongly recommend this place !
It's been years since I last had stuffed pizza from Pizza Extreme, but it was just as delicious as I remembered. The crust was flaky and buttery, the sauce tasted fresh, and there was plenty of cheese. I won't wait as long to try it again next time.
Probably the best pizza you could get for the cost. Rugular pizzas are good and the deep dish is the best thing ever. It works well for a pizza place by the university.
Delicious pizza and friendly management! They made me a gluten-free pizza using the Daiya cheese I brought along. Thank you, everyone!
Book a table now
This pizza was the worst. I would not give it any stars. It was dry and disgusting, I threw it away.
Best pizza I've ever had. Personal favorite of chicago style pepperoni, salami, sausage and pesto.
Southern Style Chicken Fritter Tenders
Hand-Tossed Veggie Version Pizza
Chicago Style Stuffed Byo Pizzas
Smothered Crispy Baby Back Ribs
Classic Hand-Tossed Byo Pizzas
Extreme Boneless Chicken Bites
Mozzarella, Tomato Basil Salad
Bacon Onion Cheeseburger Pizza
Hand-Tossed Bucky Melt Pizza
Stuffed Veggie Version Pizza
