"Great food, the Manager Pasquale was wonderful, he stopped by our table often to refill our drinks ask if we enjoyed our food. Very enjoyable......now our favorite place to eat."
I had higher expectations for the menu, but since it was our first visit and we came at night, I wasn't aware of the breakfast options. We decided to dine outside because it was a bit chilly inside, but it seemed like the staff forgot about us for a while. I ordered the fried chicken dinner with mashed potatoes, which was incredibly tasty, but the portions were on the small side and the chicken was a bit thin. Still, it was delicious! My daughter had the chicken fingers, and my partner ordered something else, but all the food was great. As we were leaving, the manager came out and offered us a complimentary apple pie for having to wait outside alone, and that made the whole meal worth it. It...
The sausage was dangerously undercooked. The manager told me he was going to make the kitchen aware and make sure they cook to temp every time. The potatoes were soggy. Like? really soggy. Coffee took 20 minutes? Gonna say it was a bad morning forthem, hopefully that?s not normal. I?m giving two stars because the manager owned the mistake very honestly and told me not topay a dime, and he said he hopes we return and have a better experience. He did take a while to get to us but I?d imagine therewere a few customers with similar issues today. Hope things are better next time I try them out. I?ve heard a lot of goodthings but I was disappointed today.
On a crisp autumn morning, as the sun began to warm the air, we stopped by Polly for breakfast. It was 8:15, and the display at the pier featured some enticing pumpkin cake, among other treats. We were quickly seated by the masked staff and enjoyed a delightful breakfast. Since pumpkin flavors are all the rage, I had to try the pumpkin-spiced coffee, which had a relatively mild and very pleasant taste. I also had the breakfast burrito, which was complemented by a small cup of fresh fruit. I can’t wait for my next visit to sample some cake!
Now that I'm close to Polly's, I've come for more than just the cakes. The breakfast is fantastic, with options like roasted chicken steak, some of the finest link sausages, and delightful baked goods such as muffins, cornbread, biscuits, and fresh-baked bread to choose as your toast. The halibut with macadamia nuts I had for lunch was a delicious dish. The burgers are amazing, and I can't wait to explore more of the menu!
Book a table now
It didn't live up to the hype for me. I'm from Georgia, where we tend to prefer sweeter flavors! I've visited a few times to sample different pies but have been unable to buy any because of their limited availability. The staff is friendly, and the restaurant is clean and well-organized. Unfortunately, this place just doesn't suit my taste.
Great!Great!Great! I always enjoy my time at Pollys. Well run and great surroundings. I love their devoted, attentive, personnel. The food is never disappointing, and desert is the best weather it be the ice coffe, cinnamon bun, or pie of yourchoice, (try the peach pie) you will not be disappointed.
The food was quite enjoyable—I had the tuna melt—but they were out of several pie options. The restaurant was also short-staffed, which left our waiter a bit overwhelmed. I may check on the pie availability before my next visit, but I really liked the renovations and the updated menu.
I absolutely love Polly's Pies! It was my first visit, and I was pleasantly surprised by how friendly everyone was. The entire place was immaculate! I ordered a Banberry Pie to take with me since I was traveling out of state. I highly recommend this place!
Book a table now
Meal was devious, but service sadly slow... table next us wad seated after our but their order was taken first and our oder came much later... I even had to inquire on the delay. Items were slow arriving.. one person's roll and jam was added for2xs.
Great food, the Manager Pasquale was wonderful, he stopped by our table often to refill our drinks ask if we enjoyed our food. Very enjoyable......now our favorite place to eat.
