Have been ordering from here over 5 years. The past 3 times including tonight the quality went down hill for sure . My husband and I both noticed. Even tried mixing up my usual order to a few different things I’ve liked and tonight was the last time I’ll be ordering. The Alfredo sauce was watery and didn’t have a good flavor , I got maybe 4 shrimp in the whole dish. The stuffed clams are for sure frozen and had that freezer burn taste. For over $60 could have made it at home way better. This is unfortunate because I loved this restaurant and was my go to !! Really didn’t even care about the hour wait for the food because we know they get busy but after waiting so long I expected decent food....
Pomodoro Rosso Italian Grill Pizzeria
5 RT-36, 07716-1109, Atlantic Highlands, United States Reservation"Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free options"
Details
Phone: +17322910390
Address: 5 RT-36, 07716-1109, Atlantic Highlands, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: Atlantic Highlands
Opening hours
Monday: 11:00-20:55
Tuesday: 11:00-20:55
Wednesday: 11:00-20:55
Thursday: 11:00-20:55
Friday: 11:00-20:55
Saturday: 11:00-20:55
Sunday: 11:00-19:55
Statistics
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 779
Address
Reviews
We ordered catering for a party of 70 people for our daughter’s birthday today. I rarely write reviews but felt the need too after receiving so many compliments about the food. Numerous people left saying they will be ordering for their next party or want to give the pizza a try now. Ordering was easy and they were so incredibly helpful. The amount of food we received was more than we expected. Will be ordering again for all our future parties. We can’t recommend them enough. Thank you again! The food made the party even more special!
I share my experience with this pizzeria because I was very satisfied.One of the best pizzas I've eaten in recent timesI also recommend the restaurant, the quantity of dishes is plentiful and very, very goodI rate this place as excellent, quality, goodness and courtesy at the top
Had chicken parm hero b4 and it was very good! Tonight a change in my feelings, Chicken was hard to chew and also almost burnt! Eggplant was like a hero slopped together and no feeling into it... Never again will I order from Book a table now
We ordered a pizza tonight, were charged for it, but it was never delivered, and now they’re closed. This is unbelievable...
This is my go to pizza place and I also had them cater my baby shower and everything was great a lot of food for a great
Had there pizza and chicken parm sub there were just ok nothing crazy. Not bad but not that great
I really enjoy the food here, and the staff is excellent; their behavior is very gracious. Book a table now
Excellent pizza, Wings are mid. Hate being overcharged for wingdings.
Dietary restrictions: They have gluten free options
Dishes
Book a table now
Categories
-
Delivery Services
-
North American
-
American
-
Italian
-
Pizza
Amenities
-
Wheelchair Accessible Seating
-
Credit Card Payments
-
American Express
- Table reservation
-
Staff Wear Masks
-
Good For Groups
- Reservation
Amici Pizzeria
2387 NJ-36, 07716, Atlantic Highlands, US, United States
Reservation, Chicken Wings, Pizzeria, Italian, Cheese, Pizza
"The pizza was delicious with a nice thin, crispy crust and arrived hot. I really enjoyed it."
Victory Park Tavern
21 W River Rd, RUMSON, United States
Reservation, Delivery Services, North American, Bar-lounge, American, Full
"Delicious food, wonderful atmosphere, and excellent service. I will definitely return!"
Kings Arms 2 Diner
553 NJ-36, 07718, Middletown, US, United States
Reservation, Delivery Services, North American, Vegetarian, American, Casual
"The best place to eat clean quality of food excellent"
The Wine Bar Restaurant
40 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, United States Of America, 07716
Reservation, Delivery Services, International, Pizza, Tapas, Wine
"Great place for an event. Wedding reception was beautiful."
Barnacle Bill's
1 1st St, 07760, RUMSON, United States
Reservation, Delivery Services, North American, American, Seafood, Burgers
"I've been visiting Barnacle Bill's since I was a kid, and it's just as amazing as I remember it from twenty years ago. You really can't go wrong with a burger at this place!"