Honestly, those wings were among the top three worst I've ever tasted, and I've had my fair share of terrible wings! I tried various flavors and expected to find some extra sauce in the containers, especially with the hot and barbecue buffalo wings, but they were completely dry. The wings themselves were nearly inedible; they were so under-sauced that it felt like they had been briefly tossed in sauce, then rinsed off to remove any remaining flavor, and finally microwaved for just 15 seconds. It was truly perplexing. To top it off, the ranch dressing tasted expired and made me feel nauseous. It was a huge waste of money, as I ended up having to buy dinner again.
I was initially hesitant, but my wife and I decided to try something different instead of our usual spot, Mark's. I'm so glad we did! The staff was friendly when I picked up our order, and we absolutely loved the pizza and wings. Both were cooked to perfection and incredibly delicious. Great job! We'll definitely be returning for our pizza Sundays!
If you're not ordering your pizza from Pontillo's through their website, you're really missing out. They have fantastic pizza, speedy delivery, and it's always served hot. Plus, they offer coupons and rewards discounts. It's definitely one of the best places in Rochester!
I hadn't visited this place in 15 years, and I'm amazed that it hasn't changed at all. I can't wait to return to Rochester to enjoy more of their pizza!
Book a table now
We ordered a sheet pizza and it was outstanding. Whenever we visit Rochester to see family, this is one of our favorite pizza spots.
By far my favorite sheet pizza in Rochester. Always consistently good. Unfortunately it’s probably causing me to gain weight ?
Best pizza in Rochester. Wings are great. Service is great. Manager clearly knows what their doing. Love Pontillo's.
The last 2 pizzas weren't great, but the one we ordered today was spectacular! We love Pontillo's pizza!
Book a table now
Been coming here 20 plus years and nothing has changed. Best pizza and wings around.
Food was awesome.Calzone was the best I've had in ages!
10 Piece Finger Lg Fry Combo
Sheet Traditional (32 Piece)
5 Piece Finger Sm Fry Combo
Garlic Bread With Mozz Roni
Xtra Large White Pizza (20
Medium Buffalo Chicken (12
Xtra Large Pink Pizza (20
Large Buffalo Chicken (16
