Great Food!. My wife and I got stuck in Sheridan after hitting a deer on our trip through WY to the west coast. We had a few days to explore while our car was being fixed (thanks to Hammer's Collision) so we took the recommendations from some locals to try the Pony. My wife had a the Bronc burger with fries and i had their Triple combo (sandwich, salad, soup) Turkey w/ provolone and raspberry sauce, garden salad with honey mustard and their cream of Reuben soup. The food was excellent, the time for the food to come out was a little slow. Popcorn is their freebie in the restaurant. Good selection of beers on tap and in bottle.
I was absolutely surprised about this place I am definitely coming back! It's a great atmosphere, and you can tell all of the employees are working hard. Nobody is standing around. The coffee was so good I could drink it black which I usually dont do. I also have to eat gluten free and was pleasantly surprised when I found out they had gluten free buns. Our food was on our table in less than 10 minutes and everything tasted great! I would highly recommend this place! I will be bringing friends next time!!!
We really enjoyed the atmosphere here. We got in fairly quickly, even with a group of 7, and we're well served. Our server, Alissa, was top notch. She got our drinks and appetizers going quickly. Interacted with the whole table, laughed, and made great recommendations. Checked on us often and made us feel welcomed. As for the food there is a good variety and we enjoyed everything we tried.
we were not disappointed in the mood for a good burger and pony bar grill. we have the regular cheeseburger with tweebel rings. their wobble rings were huge. burgers were boiled medium that was perfect. so they were in doses, so no free refills, but we were in order. they also give a small discount when they pay with cash. we would definitely return.
Book a table now
This was my first visit, and I'm so glad I came. Sheridan from Chicago, IL was our waitress, and she was fantastic! The food was amazing, and the terrace offered a wonderful atmosphere. The photos truly showcase just how great the food was here!
This review might come across as unusually dull, considering my brief stay in Sheridan, WY. Don't let the three-star rating mislead you; I genuinely enjoyed my experience here...
I visited this restaurant for lunch today and tried their Shrimp Po Boy special. The shrimp was sautéed in a sauce that had a subtle Cajun kick, and it was absolutely excellent!
The food is really good. Usually the service is so bad you can't fit it in for a normal lunch hours. It's very crowded, but the drinks are really tall.
Book a table now
Great food great service. The waitress was so polite made the meal even better
Awesome food, I recommend ask the guys about the “covrigi” You will thank me
