The restaurant was conveniently located for us and the menu looked good. When we arrived they had no means of checking a reservation and didn't have a table ready for us. It took about 15 minutes for anyone to greet our table at all, so we were able to already decide on our dinner by the first time a server talked to us. It then took another 25-30 minutes for our dinner to arrive. We had a Caesar salad, sliders, and lobster mac and cheese and I wouldn't order any of it again. The beer was good and it seemed like a fun place. There was live music that was really good, but the whole place was so loud it was impossible to have a conversation.
Primi Italian Steakhouse
999 Montauk Hwy West Islip, NY 11795, 11795-4341, United States Reservation"I think they were short-staffed. Waitress was frazzled...food was okay."
Details
Phone: +16315269779
Address: 999 Montauk Hwy West Islip, NY 11795, 11795-4341, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: West Islip
Website: http://www.primiitalian.com/
Opening hours
Tuesday: 17:00-21:00
Wednesday: 17:00-21:00
Thursday: 17:00-21:00
Friday: 17:00-22:00
Saturday: 17:00-22:00
Sunday: 16:00-20:30
Statistics
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 2019
Address
Reviews
My party was unable to be seated because 7 Hills does not accept reservations on Sunday. I was highly disappointed by this because my party had gotten together to celebrate an anniversary and after waiting for over an hour, we decided to leave and dine elsewhere. They informed me they had notified Open Table, that they do not accept Sunday reservations several times. I use OpenTable for all my reservations and have never had an issue like this.
This restaurant does not accept reservations on open table. Although we made a reservation a month in advance they did not honor it. I complained that they had our info and could have called us to let us know so we could make other arrangements. Only then they agreed to finally seat us. The place is the IT spot right now. Arrive early on Sundays otherwise you may not get seated. The food is home cooked with love.
Atmosphere was good, staff friendly. Pub food was ok during happy hour. At dinner... Seafood dishes was terrible! We ordered Pan seared scallops, shrimp & grits I've had much better, seafood pasta dish awful. I just think the entrees need work. But the DJ was good for late night entertainment! Book a table now
Even though you can make a reservation on THEIR website, they do not want to honor it. The waitress was baffled at a reservation. It gets busy and super loud to the point that even though you are yelling in someone's ear....they can't hear you.
Had a good time, the seafood boil is the best thing on the menu. Didn't really enjoy the appetizers. Will definitely return for the seafood boil, great flavor, large portion and reasonable price.
I had the best time...everyone was profesional, personable and friendly. The food was amaaaaaZing. Im already planning my next visit.
Music was so loud the waitress struggled to take our order. Menu in the restaurant does not match online menu from their website. Book a table now
Very good food, but super long wait for the five appetizers we ordered. Service was decent.
I think they were short-staffed. Waitress was frazzled...food was okay.
Dishes
Book a table now
Categories
-
Italian
-
Cheese
-
Pizza
-
Steak
-
Pasta
Amenities
-
Wheelchair Accessible Seating
-
Wheelchair Accessible
-
Outdoor Smoking Area
- Table reservation
-
Patio-outdoor Dining
-
Credit Card Payments
- Reservation
Post Office Cafe
130 W Main St, 11702, Babylon, United States
Reservation, American, Seafood, Chicken, Coffee, Cafe
"Very noisy. Before you go, call and ask if there is a party Wheelchair accessibility: Good, but you need to use a certain entrance"
Bella Vie
240 W Main St, 11706, Bayshore, United States
Reservation, Bar-lounge, Italian, Brunch, Wine, Pub
"These guys are always consistent. Very friendly and attentive."
Subway
282 Higbie Ln, 11795, West Islip, United States
Reservation, Sandwiches, Chicken, Salads , Salad, Meat
"Tried to use deal and the worker wouldn’t let me use it"
Panera Bread
1025 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, United States
Reservation, Sandwiches, Desserts, Salads, Pizza, Soup
"There was always a great experience. The staff is very friendly."
Casa Del Campo
1155 Deer Park Avenue, North Babylon, 11703, United States Of America
Reservation, Delivery Services, North American, Fast Food, American, Asiatic
"Single guy came to bar got served asap drinks and food was on point overall had a great experience"