"My order was mistakenly left behind and ended up being eaten by someone else. I had to wait for them to resend my order, and by the time it arrived, it was cold, and I wasn't even hungry anymore."
We were very frustrated after our experience and called back immediately, but the person who claimed to be the owner or manager made it difficult for us. When I asked if he was the manager, he hesitated and replied, "Yeah, I guess," which felt dismissive. For a small pizza that cost $30, I expected it to be cooked properly, not burnt with a hard blackened crust. Additionally, the Italian sausage was excessively salty.
We were instructed not to touch the pizza, but we wanted to see how it looked, so that was impossible to follow. My husband tried a slice first and found it nearly inedible, which only added to our disappointment. The customer service was terrible. They sent another pizza, but...
The pizza was fantastic! While I don't frequently order from this location, I felt it was important to share my thoughts. I recognize that your staff are young adults, but I believe some customer service training could be really helpful. Encouraging them to set aside their cell phones and interact more with customers would definitely enhance the experience. Thank you!
This is by far the worst restaurant to order from. I asked for a pizza with extra sauce and extra cheese, but instead, I got a regular pizza topped with peppers. I called to let them know about the mistake, and they assured me they would send a replacement pizza. It never showed up, and I couldn't reach them by phone. What a terrible experience!
I've passed by Rosati's many times, but since I've recently moved a bit closer, I decided to give it a try, and I'm really glad I did. My pizza was tasty, and the thin crust was genuinely thin—something I usually have to request extra at other places. I'm definitely planning to come back for pizza nights!
Book a table now
This was our first time dining at Rosati's, and we had a great experience. The service was excellent, the food was prepared quickly, and everything tasted fantastic. We especially enjoyed the double dough; it was really impressive. We will certainly be ordering from there again!
If you're in search of genuine Chicago Italian cuisine, this restaurant may not be the best option. The pasta was poorly prepared, the sauce lacked flavor, and the meatballs were just average. Even the garlic bread was disappointing—I ended up throwing it away.
The pizza is consistently hot and delicious, whether it's delivered or picked up. I requested the driver to bring it up 36 stairs since I had an injury and couldn't manage with my cane. I made sure to give him a generous tip to express my gratitude.
The pizza here is amazing, but the prices can get quite unreasonable because of the third-party delivery service. I'd order more often, but when the total ends up being $70 with tax, tip, and delivery fees, it feels a bit too much.
Book a table now
I ordered the Monster Meat Pizza, and OMG, it was the best pizza I've ever had! Absolutely delicious and worth every penny. The cannoli was a fantastic dessert as well; I tried the pistachio flavor.
My order was mistakenly left behind and ended up being eaten by someone else. I had to wait for them to resend my order, and by the time it arrived, it was cold, and I wasn't even hungry anymore.
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Crosstown Classic Combo Sandwich
Garlic Bread Spinach And Tomato
Mostaccioli Alforno Pasta
Italian Table Salad Small
