Update to the below: after the owner saw the review, they left me a very hostile email (in images). This is after we dropped off the remaining half of the cake in person and discussed the situation with the staff and exchanged several emails/calls.We have worked with this bakery for several birthdays over the last two years. The cakes have been amazing most of the time. We recently did a cake last week (the rugrats one), which looked great. However, all five of us noticed that the taste was off and gave a couple of us an upset stomach. We brought the remaining half of the cake by the bakery and the owner stated they didn’t taste anything strange. Instead of offering a partial refund since we...
Working with Rudy's Pastry Shop was a delightful experience! Our wedding venue provided us with two bakery options for our wedding cake, and we chose Rudy's. Scheduling our tasting appointment was a breeze, and they prepared three small cakes in our selected flavors for us to taste and take home. I'm not usually a fan of sweets and don’t typically enjoy cake, but Rudy's raspberry-filled cake was incredible! It wasn’t overly sweet, and the bright tartness was just what we needed for our spring wedding. Thank you, Rudy's! Our guests couldn't stop raving about the cake! I can't wait to enjoy the top tier on our wedding anniversary!
Working with Rudy's Pastry Shop was a delightful experience! Our wedding venue provided us with two bakery options for our cake, and we chose Rudy's. Scheduling our tasting appointment was easy, and they prepared three small cakes in flavors of our choice for us to taste and take home. Although I'm not usually a big fan of sweets or cake, I was blown away by Rudy's cake with raspberry filling. It wasn't overly sweet, and the bright tartness was just perfect for our spring wedding. Thank you, Rudy's! Our guests couldn't stop raving about the cake! I can't wait to enjoy the top tier on our wedding anniversary!
Rudy’s Pastry Shop created the most incredible cake for my friend’s baby shower. The theme was books and I had asked for a stacked book design with specific titles the cake turned out fabulous and was a million times better than the inspiration photos I provided. Everyone at the shower was amazed by the cake and most importantly the guest of honor loved it. Plus the cake tasted delicious! Thank you so much to the Rudy’s team!
Book a table now
Wow, I am amazed. Not only was the cake beautiful but the flavor was amazing, it’s all anyone was taking about. Very moist not overly sweet! I was very worried about the buttercream as I’ve had bad buttercream experiences but wow this buttercream was soft and fluffy not greasy or filmy at all. Price was very reasonable for the cake I asked for! Overall 10/10 definitely will be ordering more in the future
Thank you to Peggy and the entire team at Rudy’s for the beautiful wedding cake!From beginning to end, Rudy’s was a dream to work and made the entire process incredibly easy and gave us exactly what we wanted. Highly recommended!!!!
Thank you to everyone at Rudy’s! Our wedding cake was beautiful and tasted even better! All our guests were raving about our cake and how delicious it was. The entire team was easy to work with from start to finish!
To quote Stanley Tucci: oh my God this is sooo good And it was. My wife is a German teacher and has used Rudy 's for class celebrations....and Germania Park In Rockaway NJ can 't be wrong either!!
Book a table now
Everyone was thrilled with both the design and taste of the cake—it was just perfect! The customer service was outstanding as well!
No ready made pastrys only preorders.
Valentine's Day Cheesecake Drops (Pain Chocolate Strawberry, Peanut Butter, Amaretto Cappuccino)
Homemade Flour Tortilla With Beans, Cream And Cheese (Sencilla)
3" Heart Shaped Cheesecake (Dipped In Chocolate And Decadent)
One Dozen Beautiful White Chocolate Strawberries
Zeppole Di Giuseppe - Cannoli Or Bavarian Crème
10" Irish Chocolate Mint Mousse Pie Decorated
Traditional Homemade Irish Soda Bread Loaf
Decorated Cake Pops, Cupcakes, Or Cookies
10" Irish Chocolate Mint Mousse Pie Cake
Valentine's Day Bacon Cheesecake Drops
