My husband and I visited this restaurant for dinner tonight to celebrate our anniversary, not expecting to find a spot this year. Luckily, we were able to snag a last-minute reservation, and we were warmly attended to by the front-of-house manager, Katie. Despite the restaurant being quite busy and the kitchen facing some challenges, Katie was actively working with all the tables to ensure everyone had a pleasant evening. She stopped by our table several times to check on us, and I truly appreciated her hospitality. Katie, you made our night incredibly enjoyable, and we are grateful for your efforts. Thank you!
Consistently Good. I've been to the Bexley location five times or so in the last year, and haven't been disappointed yet. Its always good food, and usually good service. I absolutely love their pulled brisket nachos, they are a heaping mound of everything that is bad for you to eat (at least its real cheese). The Bucket may not overwhelm you with awesomeness, but they have a solid menu with enough options for everyone to find what they are looking for, and its not a bad place to catch a game (even have TVs in the bathroom so you don't miss any of the action).
An unexpected surprise! I accidentally took the wrong lane due to the intense road construction in Ohio. I wasn't able to switch over, so I ended up down a different road. While turning around, I spotted The Rusty Bucket and thought, "Why not?" It was a nice place that reminded me a bit of J. Alexander's, just on a smaller scale. The food was delicious; I had the Italian Torpedo, which I really enjoyed. Overall, it turned out to be a great find, and the service was just as good as the food.
We had visited this restaurant bar once before and left with a positive impression, primarily because I had one of the best waitresses in recent memory. The fact that they had a flatscreen showing the NHL playoffs added to the experience. On my last visit, I ordered the Elvis Velveeta Burger, and I recommended it to my girlfriend's father, who also enjoyed it. So far, that makes it four thumbs up!
Book a table now
Love the chili, which makes the Gary's Three-Way my favorite, too. And, Double Nickel salads taste great; throwback to the old 55 Restaurants. I do hold the red onions, though--a bit too potent for my liking. And, has my favorite beers and decent wine.
The area we were seated was too crowded. Our table had to be moved three (3) times for wheelchairs to enter and exit. A booth across from our table had a high chair at the end which did not permit a clear entrance and or exit or path to restrooms.
The food at this restaurant is very good and reasonably priced. The waitress Cam is charming and delightful.
We were seated right away. Our server was great our food was delicious!! We will definitely be back!!
Book a table now
Gotta love their HAPPY HOURS pricing! We come often to enjoy this time of evening.
Great happy hour prices until 6:00. Great pizza too.
Our Warm Cinnamon Sugar Donut Holes
Saturday Gary's Famous Margaritas
Triple Decker Breakfast Sandwich
Tuesday Bbq Pulled Pork Sandwich
Thursday Spaghetti 'N Meatballs
Kid's Cheesy Scrambled Eggs*
Double Nickel Chicken Salad
Double Bacon Cheddar Burger
Wednesday Beef Stroganoff
Bbq Chopped Chicken Salad
