I have always seen this restaurant on door dash and was tempted to try it, but never did until last night. Let’s just say the photos they used on door dash are NOT of their actual food. It was very underwhelming.The gnocchi pasta had almost no sauce on it and was very dry and cold. Imagine dry gnocchi with an impenetrable layer of cold hard cheese on it. And the breadstick that came with it was burnt to a literal crisp, the bread was completely black and it was hard as a rock. Like, I can’t believe that a real human picked up this horrible crispy black breadstick was like, “yeah, this looks good, I’ll stick it in with this order.”The pizza was edible in a pinch hence 2 stars instead of 1 but...
We ordered delivery of Chicken Alfredo and fries, but instead received spaghetti with tomato sauce. Surprisingly, it was delicious! The dish came with a large loaf of bread topped with a generous amount of cheese, which was really tasty. The fries were moist and even better when dipped in ketchup. The chicken was tender and flavorful, complementing the lovely spaghetti perfectly. At $16.99 for a three-person serving of this amazing Italian entrée, it was a fantastic deal. I’m at a loss for words, but I would give it a 5/5 rating. I will definitely be back for more!
We ordered two pizzas late at night, and while it took an hour for them to arrive—which might be due to using a third-party delivery service—our experience was worth the wait. We got two large pepperoni pizzas, and although they were a bit on the expensive side, the slices were sizable and absolutely delicious. The crust was soft, the cheese was gooey, and the garlic sauce they provided was a nice touch. I will definitely be ordering from here again the next time we're in the city.
Is it the best chicken Alfredo I've ever had overall? No. Is it one of the best in this price range? ABSOLUTELY. Giant portion. Definitely enough for two meals for me. Possibly three if I threw a salad or more bread with it. Also, guys working we're super friendly. I'll be back to try other things. also, make sure you pay for parking. In the literal two minutes or less it took me to run in I almost got a ticket.
Book a table now
Sicilia is a 3 if you order it for delivery, a 2 if you're an adult looking to explore Columbus, and a 5 if you're a drunk college student who desperately needs carbs and wings. I'm not sure what else to put, but this is not a place that you should find through a Yelp review.
I've always been a huge fan of Sicilia’s thin crust pizza, and I ordered one last night. However, what I found in the pizza box was a thick crust that was undercooked and greasy. It was really disappointing. I strongly suggest removing the thick crust option from your menu.
When your customers order thru food delivery services. Please seal the bag with at least a staple thru the knot. College bar food. Better if you're drunkFood: 2/5
Arguably the best slice on campus! Pizza was delicious and ready fast. Staff was friendly and the location is great.
Book a table now
We stopped here in the afternoon after picking up a package at the new Amazon station downtown.
Food was good, until my husband bit into this piece of PLASTIC in our pizza.
Meatballs (6 Giant Baked Meatballs Topped Off W/Pasta Sauce Mozzarella Provolone Cheeses)
Pizza Fries (Baked Fries Topped Off W/Pizza Sauce, Mozzarella Romano Cheeses)
Mega Fries (Baked Fries Topped Off W/Bacon, Mozzarella Cheddar Cheeses)
Pizza , Wings Soda Special: Lg 3 Item Pizza,12 Wings 3 Soda Cans
2 Large 2 Toppings Pizzas, 18 Wings And 6 Soda Cans Special
X-Large 3 Toppings Pizza, 12 Wings 3 Soda Cans Special
Any Pasta With Salad, Garlic Bread And Drink Special
Medium 2 Toppings Pizza, 6 Wings And 2 Soda Cans
Xl 3 Item Pizza 3 Soda Cans (Sunday Thurs Only)
2 Medium 2 Item Pizzas 2 Soda Cans Special
