I visited this restaurant for the first time today, and I was impressed. Everything is brand new and clean, including the bathroom. The pizza was delicious and nicely thin, with the oven really enhancing its unique flavor. I found the atmosphere to be very family-friendly, with two high chairs available and ample space for strollers. It’s a bright and tidy place to enjoy pizza. I highly recommend giving it a try! Plus, they have adorable ketchup containers that allow you to squeeze or dip, rather than the old-fashioned packets. And don't forget to leave room for dessert—the Nutella pizza is the perfect finale!
The pizzas here are fantastic! They serve thin, hand-tossed pies made with fresh ingredients. A small pizza is definitely enough for one person. I especially love the Margherita pizza, the Diablo, and the plain pizza with sausage. The owner is friendly and truly takes pride in his dishes; you can taste that love in every bite. There’s also something called The Snack pizza, which is quite heavy. It comes topped with pieces of hot dog and French fries, so you’ll want to share that small pie with others. It’s a bit unusual, but it’s worth a try, just not something I’d recommend eating alone!
This restaurant has recently changed management and now features a lovely Italian family working together. When you visit, you immediately feel at home; the atmosphere is warm and inviting, and the place is spotless. There’s a wide variety of dishes to choose from. I've tried the pizza, pasta, and dessert, and I couldn't be happier with my choices—the food is fantastic! It’s undoubtedly the best cuisine in Tuckahoe and the surrounding area. The ingredients are fresh, and everything tastes authentically Italian. I highly recommend this restaurant to everyone. Ciao!
I almost posted a negative review, but the owner's behavior changed my opinion. Here's how the meal went: The salad was great. Big deal. It's salad. The orecchietta was mush, as was the broccoli rabe; as a whole, the dish was malodorous and inedible. The wait staff seemed to have challenges with things like English (European family it seems) and keeping the waterglass full. I nearly left when the owner/chief came over and inquired after my meal. I told him what I thought and he offered to make me a pizza. Turns out the pizza was delicious. I will eat there again.
Book a table now
I've had pizza in Naples and this is as close as you will find to that in the states. I actually had a chance to talk to the owner before and he told me that he's from Naples and he came to the states and brought his oven. This place is great the only minor complaint is that it takes the oven a while to get super hot so it's actually slightly better in the afternoon than when they first open.
Overall, the Itslian Job is a decent place. The counter staff waits on you and brings your food to your table. The portions are huge and they will wrap the leftovers up for you. It is a little expensive, but overall a nice place
The pizza was awesome. Super authentic spot that was very reasonably priced. Pasta dish was also freshly made and full of flavor. Management was very kind. Would definetly return.
Real Napolitan pizza must be eaten on the spot and not taken out since it only take 1min half to cook.
Book a table now
Best best best pizza ever!!!! Real pizza finally in NY, finally in America...finally in Tuckahoe.
Friendly staff and delicious pizza. Great for kids too!
