I come here almost every day for lunch and get the same thing most of the time. Dan, the owner, is one of the reasons that sets this place apart and above other places in town. He makes you feel special because he not only knows me by name but also remembers my order. You can tell that he cares about his product and his people. He is constantly smiling and upbeat. He is always cleaning every table right after the customer leaves and making sure everyone is happy. I 've tried a few things here, but my two favorites are 'The Dip ' and the 'Lumpy '. My favorite side is by far the 'Hand Cut Fries '. They are easily the best fries in Madison. And last but not least are the drinks...they have thei...
My husband and I had Tony Boys delivered after returning from a long trip in the car. I had the roast beef sub and he had the lumpy chicken sandwich. My husband thought the lumpy was excellent, and even though it's not my thing, the bite I tried was tasty. I was happy with the roast beef, it was rare as promised on the menu. My only complaint was that the sub roll was hard. I attribute that to us placing an order late in the day. As a true sandwich lover, it was disappointing, but I'm definitely open to giving Tony Boys another try. We definitely appreciated the affordable and speedy delivery.
Ordering Tony Boy's delivery has become a weekly staple in my house. I'm not someone who will typically order a salad, but my go-to is the chop chop sandwich with eggplant and Caesar dressing. It's basically a monster Caesar salad with thin, crispyeggplant on a sub roll. And it's incredible. We've tried a few other sammies and eat happily every time. Thank goodness theydeliver all the way to Randolph, as there are no decent sub spots left out this way. Don't miss the fries or the vodka sauce,both are great.
I like Tony boys it’s solid reliable and creative. I ordered lunch from there today went back for dinner and I guess I learned my lesson not to go at night! Ordered a Oreo milkshake via online. Went to pick milkshake up and they didn’t have Oreos no problem I get it. After one sip the milkshake was just like watery cream. Very disappointed in the lack of effort put into the milkshake. Guess I will just be eating lunch here for now on!
Book a table now
Awesome quick spot for lunch. Price point and value are great. You get a lot for what you’re paying for. Got the angry bird which featured vodka sauce and honey on a chicken cutlet sandwich. It was amazing and unique combo. Will definitely be back to try more of the menu since it’s so close to the office. Staff was great too.
I love this place and will keep ordering from them, but I had to leave this review because the past few times my bread has been so stale and hard that it’s hard to enjoy the sandwich. Did you stop using fresh bread? It used to be so much better. Please go back to it!
The first time I had the sous vide rare roast beef it was rare, but this time it was only medium rare. I need to be more careful about that. The rye bread was dry. However, the mac salad was excellent. Parking was easy.
Ordered a platter of sandwiches (eggplant and chicken cutlet) and Caesar salad. They are so darn good! Will keep this place in mind for future orders!!
Book a table now
Fantastic. Staff is friendly. Food always so fresh. Best chicken cutlet in NJ. Get the #10. You will thank me later.
You should definitely check out Tony Boy's Sandwich House for great value and high-quality food.
