Toto's has become our favorite go to restaurant on Long Island. The food is amazing. We were there just yesterday for a double birthday celebration. We got there at the correct time and were welcomed by the owner who is a very lovely gentleman. Our table was being set up and he waited with us until it was ready. I asked him with a straight face if anything was good tonight. He stared at me for a second and then just belly laughed! The place was packed probably because of Restaurant Week. We had warm bread as we waited for our waiter. We ordered baked clams, the best, shrimp cocktail as apps. Our mains were grilled Bronzino, grilled Lamb Chops and Osso Bucco (always on my list of best dishes...
Not a great choice for a Valentine's dinner... I was hoping to find a nice, slightly upscale spot to treat my wife, and I was really excited about Toto's. However, it took us 45 minutes to receive our drinks. When we finally ordered our food, we were disappointed with it and asked for steak sauce. They offered A1 or homemade, and we chose the homemade option—apparently, they're still in the process of making it. We also requested two more drinks, but they never arrived. It wasn't just us; by the time the people at the table next to us received their food, the woman said, "Just wrap it up, we're leaving." I'm normally a very generous tipper, sometimes to a fault, because I appreciate good foo...
Quiet little restaurant off the beaten path. Dining there last night and the onion soup was lukewarm, our two dinners were ok, service was really slow as they were probably short-handed. The worst thing was the chairs are wood, covered with a thin cloth and I couldn't wait to leave. If we go back I will need to take a cushion for the chair. By the way the coffee was also lukewarm.
We came here to celebrate a birthday, and what a hidden gem it is! The ambiance was stunning and intimate, the food was incredibly delicious, and the service was attentive without being overbearing. Everyone was so friendly. Even though we were the last ones to leave on a Thursday night, we never felt rushed at all. Thank you for a wonderful evening. We will definitely return!
Book a table now
The restaurant is situated behind the Jone Beach Hotel. When we arrived, we were warmly welcomed and promptly seated since we had made reservations. Both the drinks and food were excellent, with the shareable portions suitable for more than two people. Our waitress was friendly and attentive to our needs. We will definitely be returning, as we had a wonderful experience.
We had 2:45 reservations on a Saturday afternoon, so their were only a few tables occupied. The food was delicious and the waiter was excellent. It is a nicely decorated comfortable place with a nice bar as you come in. We will be going back as we were looking for place like this on the South Shore. Try it they are very welcoming.
Totos Restaurant is my favorite restaurant. Tom, the owner always greets and welcomes us and Shimmy, Raul and the rest of the staff always goes above and beyond to ensure that our dining experience is pleasurable. The menu offers a variety of delicious foods that would tempt any palate. Highly recommended.
Hidden gem in wantagh! Came tonight for dinner because we are staying in the Jones beach hotel Everything was excellent. The food , the ambiance and the service were all amazing. Highly recommend the grilled octopus with broccoli rabe! And the tiramisu is outstanding!
Book a table now
Met friends for dinner and were seated in the back room. The service was great, very professional and welcoming. We all really enjoyed our food and the standout dish was the chicken tre fungi. We had a great evening!
Service was excellent and food very good! Just a little too noisy with the one man band in a small area. If he was in the bar area he still Would have been heard but not as loud. He was great; played good songs.
