After being a loyal customer for many years, I was disappointed to discover a decline in the pizza quality at this restaurant. The new pizza maker doesn't prepare the pizzas like they once did; they're now dry and lacking in sauce, cheese, and toppings. I spent $39 on two pizzas that had minimal toppings and insufficient sauce and cheese. Despite my repeated requests for extra sauce, the pizza maker didn't seem to take them into account. I wouldn't recommend this place if you're seeking quality. Additionally, the strong sewer odor coming from the laundromat next door was quite off-putting. It's unclear whether they have addressed this issue.
Valentinos Pizza - Table reservation
1597 Manatuck Blvd, 11706, Bay Shore, US, United States Reservation"It's a solid choice—not the top Peruvian restaurant out there, but still quite enjoyable."
Details
Phone: +16316665172
Address: 1597 Manatuck Blvd, 11706, Bay Shore, US, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: Bay Shore
Opening hours
Monday: 11:00-21:00
Tuesday: 11:00-21:00
Wednesday: 11:00-21:00
Thursday: 11:00-21:00
Friday: 11:00-21:00
Saturday: 08:00-22:00
Sunday: 08:00-22:00
Statistics
Dishes: 10
Categories: 5
Reviews: 610
Address
Reviews
I had a very disappointing experience with this restaurant. The staff who took my order over the phone were incredibly rude, and they messed up my order without offering any refunds or exchanges. There was a complete lack of effort to provide good customer service. I faced a major issue with them that led me to boycott the restaurant for nearly a year. I decided to give them another chance, but unfortunately, they made the same mistakes again. This is a terrible way to run a business.
The food was delightful, although the service could definitely be better. The dishes had a wonderfully comforting flavor. For dinner, the delivery was quick, but the overall service experience was just okay. The cost per person ranged from $20 to $30. In summary, I would give the food a 5, the service a 3, and the atmosphere a 5. I highly recommend trying the Arrow Chaufa and Antichuchos Con Rachi.
This is NOT an authentic Peruvian restaurant. The caldo de gallina was nothing more than chicken broth with a few pieces of chicken and overcooked spaghetti. The aji lacked flavor and was quite disappointing. I will definitely not be ordering from here again. If I could, I would give it zero or half a star (just for the effort). Book a table now
The prices on the menu are outdated, as I learned from the person I spoke to on the phone. Everything that's advertised is now at least double the listed price. The staff I interacted with seemed confused and uninformed about their offerings. It feels like false advertising, and the service was quite poor.
I observed him picking up my food from the restaurant, then he drove to the mall for 35 minutes. After that, he spent another 15 minutes at a nearby house! By the time I received my food, it was cold!
The restaurant offers subpar service and does not prioritize good customer care. The food quality is rated a disappointing 2 out of 5, and both the service and atmosphere only earn a score of 1.
Additionally, the parking situation is not ideal; the laundromat next door produces a strong sewer smell that is quite off-putting. Book a table now
I’ve visited this restaurant twice, and both times have been exceptional. The staff is friendly, and the food is delicious!
It's a solid choice—not the top Peruvian restaurant out there, but still quite enjoyable.
Dishes
Book a table now
Categories
-
Delivery Services
-
Peruvian
-
Italian
-
Chicken
-
Pizza
Amenities
-
Wheelchair Accessible Seating
-
Wheelchair Accessible
-
Accepts Credit Cards
- Table reservation
-
Curbside Pickup
-
Good For Groups
- Reservation
The Penny Pub
79 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA, United States
Reservation, Breakfast, Salad, Lunch, Pubs, Pub
"Stopped in for a drink. Got some wings. Crowd is friendly staff is welcoming."
Pico Tequilla Grill Of Bay Shore
19 W Main St, 11706, Bayshore, United States
Reservation, Vegetarian Friendly, Mexican, Grill, Tapas, Salad
"Good food reasonably priced. Great happy hour. Friendly bartender. Makes a great Margarita."
H2O Seafood & Sushi - East Islip
166 W Main St East Islip, NY 11730, 11730-2298, United States
Reservation, Seafood, Chicken, Pizza, Sushi, Soup
"This restaurant is closed. Open Table must be removed from the list."
Yong Wang Kitchen
31 NY-27A, 31 W Main St, East Islip, NY 11730, USA, United States
Reservation, Seafood, Chinese, Chicken, Soup, Meat
"no taste, really slandered. very small huh generally tso’s huh. knödel were decent"
The Tap Room
44 E Main St, 11706, Bay Shore, United States
Reservation, Curbside Pickup, Breakfast, American, Lunch, Full
"Nice laid back atmosphere. Good food and drinks."