I have been going here since I was a kid I now live 40 minutes away I travel past five other pizza shops to get their meals because they are the best. Their sauce is amazing and can't be compared to anyone else. Their dough and crust are thin and crunchy as it's supposed to be. They customize our order every time we go because of how far away we live. They are a little pricey but that's what it takes to stay in business these days and definitely worth it. To all the people who left less than four stars as a review, they are just whiners who think they are entitled to restaurant service from a pizza shop. They are definitely in a remote location and worth the drive. The reason they don't deli...
This restaurant is simple and straightforward, serving delicious pizza slices. It's a charming 49-year-old family-run business in West Milford that has remained unchanged throughout its history. They don’t try to be anything fancy—it's as casual as you can get—and they don’t put on airs when all you want is a slice of pizza and a Snapple. The owner, who seems quite busy, takes your order while chatting with someone else behind the counter. Old, now-unused coin-operated bubble gum machines line the wall, and the small menu—likely very similar to what they offered back in the mid-70s—is displayed in bright red letters, reminiscent of the pizza places we all grew up with. This place is absolute...
Small pizza shop where if you blink you could miss it, but it's definitely worth the stop. Slices are really good quality and better than many of the more well know places in the area. Menu is a little limited and it's definitely a place where you are taking the food to go as seating is sparce. Overall we liked the pizza very much.
The best pizza around! My son lives out of state, and whenever he comes home, he always goes straight to Vesuvio's. The staff and food are exceptional. You absolutely have to try this pizza!
Book a table now
This WAS the best place to go for pizza in West Milford area. It's under new owners and unfortunately, in my opinion, has gone downhill. The pizza I had was NOT good. I will not be back.
Pizza was middle of the road. Atmosphere was eh. This was your average slice of pizza. Finally, I would only recommend if you’re in a hurry. 6/10 average pizza.
Take out only since the atmosphere is terrible with only 1 or 2 tables. The prices keep going up. The pizza's and food is very good.
I tried the Sicilian pie for the first time and it was fantastic! Great job, everyone!
Book a table now
First time and found Great food and prices. Will go back. (also no one was rude)
As good as I've had. Their pizza sauce is exceptional.
