My girlfriend came over for dinner for the first time, and she brought with her all the way from Shorts in Coldwater this Yoders Peanut Butter Pie. I don 't know if I was happier to see her at my door or a peanut butter pie in her hands. Either way, I couldn 't wait for dessert. Little did she know that peanut butter pie is my favorite. Well it wasn 't very long after dinner that I said ok, time for dessert . What a surprise it was when I took a bite of that creamy goodness. It was fantastic! So the main filling is this vanilla cream topped with a whipped topping. The peanut butter is a layer just above the crust in the bottom of the pan. I did a breakdown the next morning when I had a bite...
This place is awesome! I stopped in and so glad I did. This place is a deli counter, bakery, restaurant salad bar, homemade salads, grilled meats, and bulk items. Ordered a small sandwich from the deli counter for $2.99 and a small cucumber/tomato salad. Total bill: $5.04 Sandwich was excellent and filling. You get to pick what items you want on the sandwich. The cucumber/tomato salad was fresh and reminded me of my grandmother's salad. So good and filling. I walked around the store and was impressed with how clean and friendly all the staff were. The prices for baked goods was reasonable and I will definitely try the next time I visit. This place is awesome. Trust.
Six years ago, our neighbor Carol introduced us to this place, and we have been coming here every weekend during the summer ever since. We love the veggies with ranch, deli meats, salads, fresh bread, and occasional donuts. I always make sure to stock up on jam to last us through the Chicago winters. The food here is always fresh and unique, and the staff are incredibly helpful and nice. Yoder's at Lake Templene is a standout for me, and I am grateful to the team for their kindness towards our friend Carol. Thank you for everything. Carol loved Yodies.
I know someone who works at a social service agency across the street from Yoder's, and she told me that she goes there for lunch five days a week. The deli and bakery at the restaurant are great, but we especially love the bakery. Recently, we bought some carrot cake muffins and lemon bars, and they were delicious. However, we are not fans of their cheese-based soups because they use Velveeta as a base. No amount of money could convince me that a broccoli Velveeta soup is actually a broccoli cheese soup.
Book a table now
We came in for donuts and walked out with a cart full of homemade, delicious food! The donuts were to die for the cream filled and cinnamon caramel powdered sugar were our favorites. We also enjoyed a chicken pot pie, brisket, pulled pork, and all the sides pasta and potato salads, cole slaw (chopped and excellent! , Mac n cheese, etc. Highly recommend!!
Great food is an understatement. Whether it's the fresh donuts, the fresh salad bar, the deli, or even their bulk items; it is all superb! An overall great family friendly atmosphere.
OMG! The Peanut Butter Pie is the best!!!! I saw the reviews thought we'd give a try best decision. I wish we bought more Nice little store, nice people who work there
The items sold at Yoder's may be expensive, but the food is delicious. I have been enjoying their donuts since I was five years old.
Book a table now
Must stop when passing through town. Many great lunch sandwich options and must remember to grab donuts for the road!
You'll be amazed! Stop by and get their delicious breakfast pizza and/or Casserole in the morning.
Cooper's Sharp White American Cheese
Walnut Creek American Cheese Slices
Schnitzel (Fried, Breaded Chicken)
Country Market Gold Crown Onions
Old Fashioned Peppered Gravy Mix
Pargiyot (Grilled Baby Chicken)
Veggie, Mac & Cheese Or Cheesy
Walnut Creek Imported Deli Ham
Grab & Go Rib Dinner & Potpie
Peppered With Sausage Flavor
