While the food was beautifully presented, I was hoping for more flavor from my scallop pesto entree. Unfortunately, the scallops didn’t have the sweetness or richness I expected, and the pesto flavor was quite subtle. Overall, the dish felt lacking in flavor and depth. On a brighter note, the crab cake appetizer met my expectations, and my husband thoroughly enjoyed his entree, although I can’t recall what he ordered—just one of the daily specials.
Both of our salads were fresh and full of flavor, but what truly stood out to us at Alexander's was the outstanding service from Romeo. He was attentive without being intrusive, ensuring timely delivery of our courses without ever leaving us want...
Expert service, cozy atmosphere, delicious elevated fare is what you'll find at Alexander's. The front entrance brings you into a lively, mood lit bar with plenty of bar and lounge seating. Recommend grabbing a Wisconsin old fashioned before your meal. The reservation desk is tucked across from the restrooms where you will get a tiny buzzer that will alert you when your table is ready. Alexander's is one of the finest dining experiences one can have in Door County! I loved the Saturday night special, tenderloin a la Oscar. It was cooked to perfection, with a lovely presentation of an edible flower and julianne vegetables. My husband enjoyed the ample king cut portion of prime rib. The servic...
This place is amazing. I haven't been here is a VERY long time. So long ago it was their old location. They were packed on entry and were goi g to have us wait a minute for our reservation. They noticed someone in our party that was old/walker/ difficulty standing and they immediately seated upon seeing this. So kind and thoughtful. They didn't need to do this. Drink menu was great. Love the cocktail choices and they were really reasonable with pricing. Dinner the walleye was fantastic and all the sides with it. Everyone else in the party loved their entrees too. In short, everything was off the rails amazing. So good! We ordered three deserts too. I probably would not order the tiramisu aga...
Once again, fantastic food and service. Had a 5:45 reservation, so checked in and grabbed a drink at the bar. Our table was quickly ready, and we perused the menu. I got the Walleye Pike and my wife got the Stuffed Shrimp this time around. I got Blue Cheese dressing with my salad and got the crumbles (delicious! and the dressing. My serving of Walleye was huge! And sooo tasty. My wife's shrimp was pretty decadent and very good. The house veggies were delicious, as were the potatoes. Our server, Romeo, was amazing, as were the bartenders, bidders, hosts, and everyone else we came across. Romantic atmosphere, as well as a vibrant bar scene. Just a great experience.
Book a table now
Food was above average, servers were attentive. Where I have issue however is the timeliness of reservations. I made reservations over a week in advance for 2 people for 6:30pm. When we arrive at 6:30, we were told there's no tables available. They gave us a pager and asked us to take a seat along with a couple of dozen other people. 45 minutes later we were seated. What's the point of making a reservation if it isn't honored? Just make the seating a first come-first served and make it equal for everyone.
We came in late March for mini vacation. We have never tried Alexander's before. Our experience at Alexander's was an amazing. The environment was elegant. The food presentation was beyond beautifully. I had the special meal, Sea Bass with asparagus and mashed potatoes mixed in with lobster sauce(that was out of imagination, but what a perfect flavor I ever had)! My husband had the steak which he said the cut and how it was cooked. The desserts were so delicious. Definitely will come back again.
Alexander's is just a great experience from the moment you arrive. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. The drinks are a great pour and the food is always fantastic. We love their version and presentation of the escargot. The soups are also always outstanding. I'm partial to the chicken or pork prepared Chloe style--it's a rich but balanced creamy mushroom sauce and my husband loves the filet mignon, Oscar style. Do yourself a favor and make sure that Alexander's is in your rotation.
The food was excellent, served in a charming atmosphere. While it wasn't a groundbreaking culinary experience, it was definitely delicious. We ordered the broiled whitefish accompanied by a cup of lobster bisque. The scalloped potatoes were slightly salty but still enjoyable, and the green beans were delightful. The lobster bisque could have been thicker with more lobster pieces, but it had a good overall flavor. Our server was wonderful, and the ambiance was pleasant.
Book a table now
The food here is fantastic, and the service is exceptional. The staff is cheerful and very accommodating. From the appetizers to the soup, salad, and main course, everything is of the highest quality.
We absolutely love Alexander's! We've been here many times and nothing disappoints. There are so many wonderful options that it is always hard to choose, but you can't go wrong.
