I was on my way to a work assignment around noon and was planning on skipping lunch, but I saw the storefront out of the corner of my eye as I was driving by. Still having a 70's era Coke sign with your restaurant name on it means the owners either have supreme confidence or complete apathy about their business, and since I was craving a slice, a made a U-turn to find out which one it was. The physical building probably has not seen an upgrade inside or out since Jimmy Carter was president. Red vinyl cushion stools at the counter on one side, shabby tables on the right and you have to walk through the kitchen to get to the bathrooms. This is my kind of place!!! I sat at the counter half way...
I called the restaurant to request a replacement or a refund for the incorrect order. The person who answered the phone was very polite, but after a short wait, another employee came on the line and shouted, "If you wanted light cheese, you should have asked for it!" I was shocked to be spoken to like that, especially considering I've been a loyal customer, usually ordering weekly. This was my first complaint, and the person’s hostility was completely unwarranted.
I tried to explain that my order didn’t come with light cheese or even regular cheese, but they continued to talk over me and raised their voice further. Eventually, I felt I had no choice but to raise my voice in response. I shou...
I ordered 2 BLT club sandwiches and received 2 of the most skimpy sandwiches I've ever seen. They didn't even use 3 pieces of bread as a club sandwich is supposed to it was 2 pieces of bacon crumbled on 2 pieces of bread with very little else. I'm very disappointed and will never order from here again. Thanks for literally nothing
I’m not sure what’s happening with Conestoga-style pizza, but I was quite disappointed with my order. The pizza stromboli lacked flavor, and the pizza itself was similarly bland. I hope they can improve things in the future.
Book a table now
The hispanic guy who made our pizza was especially friendly and nice. He is a great worker too. Conestoga Pizza is lucky to have a guy like that. Vegetarian options: Its the main line so they accommodate.
Absolutely delicious stopped in on our way to kalahari for a family vacation and this place may not look like it's amazing but the service and the food were absolutely delicious. Amazing.
As a truck driver passing through, I stopped by for a slice of pizza. It was absolutely delicious! The staff was also very friendly, making my visit even more enjoyable.
Best pizza in Pennsylvania!. I've been eating here the last 45 years.Great food,great srevice.The best around!. I love it.
Book a table now
We ordered fried chicken it tasted sour and burned. Can’t you check the quality before you give the order to customer?
The food here has always been outstanding. I've been coming for 45 years.
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Buffalo Chicken Stromboli
Fried Shrimp (Butterfly) Platter
Conestoga Special Club Platter
Cheeseburger Deluxe Platter
Conestoga Special Stromboli
Chicken Souvlaki Sandwich
