Dimatteos's Pizza Pasta

Staying in Point Pleasant Beach for a few days and We ordered a Grandmas pie 25 and a garden salad 12.50 . Sorry to say it was VERY disappointing . The pizza was WAY Overcooked. The crust was like cardboard and it was burnt . The cheese was so thin that you could barely taste it.only redeeming factor was the sauce was good. The salad was 90% lettuce. Like the core of romaine and iceberg ..with a few items sprinkled on top . Never again To the owners response : We are fully aware of how a grandma’s pie is made, which is why we ordered it. It was not thin and crispy, it was VERY over, cooked and Burned !! And it’s supposed to be fresh mozzarella, which is not paper thin. And the salad was abso...

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Their pasta dishes are the best I have ever had from a pizza restaurant and so are the burgers. HELL everything is delicious! ! The chili wings, crazy good. If you don't feel like going out to eat you must order from them you won't be disappointed. Update 6/20/23. The pizza was good but everything else... cheesesteak salty and a little burnt, the chicken wings and zucchini fries you can tell are frozen. Covid has changed everything but charging higher prices and serving less quality food is bad business. The quality should never change it should be consistent. Would only recommend the pizza.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Amazing place. Love the food. Service was amazing. Big shout out to the kind boy working at the front Sean, after greeting me with my order he proceeding to give me a back massage. Love this place.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Terrific specialty slices! Too many to list, always changing, visit them and check it out. Real close to the beach during summer time as well

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply

Just went in to get a single slice to go and a garlic knot. excellent pizza and inexpensive. Will go back when I come back to NJ.

• Useful
• Not Useful
• Reply