I want to start by saying that I called on a Friday afternoon and didn't get an answer, but I quickly received a call back acknowledging my call. That alone shows they truly care about their customers. It was last minute, and they didn't have the time slot I needed, but they said they would reach out if there were any cancellations. About an hour later, they called me back to let me know they could accommodate me at my desired time. Which restaurant takes the time to save your number and follow up about a cancellation? I'm so glad they did, as the food and service were outstanding! I loved the cozy yet classy old Italian atmosphere in the neighborhood. There’s nothing pretentious about this...
We celebrated my 14th anniversary here and returned for my birthday, and I can't say enough about this restaurant. It’s truly fantastic. The food is excellent, and the service is outstanding. You won't have to wait for anything, as the waitstaff collaborates seamlessly to assist every table. And don't miss the Pappardelle Alla Bolognese—it’s incredible! Having grown up in an Italian household, I have high standards for sauce and pasta, and this dish exceeded my expectations. After visiting several times and consistently receiving the same wonderful experience, it's clear how exceptional this place is. A huge thank you to the staff and chef for their efforts. Well done, and please keep up the...
What a fantastic discovery! I'm almost hesitant to share it because making reservations might be tougher now. The food is simply incredible! We started with the burrata appetizer paired with figs, following the delicious bruschetta that is served at every table. We were already quite full before our main course, yet we somehow managed to finish every bite of my spinach manicotti, while my husband polished off his spaghetti with clam sauce. He even treated himself to the Italian cheesecake—absolutely amazing! Our server, Alex, was exceptionally friendly and attentive. Several staff members came by to check on us, and they even offered us limoncello to enhance our dining experience. It was a w...
I can't begin to describe how fantastic this restaurant is! My fiancé and I decided to check it out on a whim, and we were beyond delighted with our experience. From the moment we stepped inside, the service was outstanding. Angel and Victor were especially wonderful, making our evening unforgettable with their attentive and friendly approach. And the food? Absolutely incredible! We've discovered our new favorite place, and I can’t wait to go back!
Book a table now
I can't rave about this restaurant enough. The quality of the food is exceptional, especially the handmade pasta, which is fresh and delicious. The service is warm and friendly, with servers who seem genuinely happy to be there. It's truly a gem in Islip. In fact, I'm going to make another reservation right now!
The food was excellent; however, the fried calamari could have been crispier. The staff was exceptionally attentive. The restaurant is a bit small, and when it's busy, the acoustics make it quite noisy. If I could, I would rate the atmosphere at 3½ stars, but that's not an option. I would definitely return!
Outstanding food and service! Il Piccolo Villaggio is undeniably among the best in the region. From the moment you walk in, the staff is exceptionally warm and attentive. This restaurant truly lives up to its excellent reputation. If you're in the area, it’s definitely a must-visit for dinner!
My husband took me there for a date and we had a wonderful time. The service from beginning to end was impeccable. A very friendly and welcoming environment that keeps you talking about the experience for days. Will be returning for sure!!
Book a table now
I wish I could give them 20 stars for their service! It has been consistently outstanding in every way. Each of my 12 visits has been perfect, and I couldn't find a single complaint. Go and enjoy!
The food was outstanding and very fresh. The pasta and chicken cutlet were cooked to perfection. The staff was courteous and attentive. It's a fantastic local spot for Italian cuisine.
