Tried to go once before but they were closed. SO GLAD we returned! Hubs got the small Stromboli I got a small Veggie Lover pizza. Oh, and, no pic but we also started with a garden salad. The portions were HUGE!!! Expected a small side salad and it was more than enough to feed two so fresh yummy. When his Stromboli my Pizza came out we burst out laughing…just knowing they had the sizes wrong. Nope, look at the pics. Both so delicious. Their sauce is so thick and yummy (no sweetness, which is great) and their crust is cooked to perfection. Fresh, nice ingredients! We have enough leftovers for an entire meal! So happy to find them. Can’t wait to try a sub and calzone. Pick up or dine in just GO...
I phoned in an order for Lasagna tonight and picked it up. It came with a salad and garlic rolls. It was still very warm when I got home. The lasagne was absolutely delicious. The noodles, sauce, and cheese were perfect. As one other reviewer stated it was a bit on the salty side but I like salt. Those who are sensitive to salt might need to order something else.I’ve had their pizza before and it’s excellent too. The lasagne was enough for another meal tomorrow.. very generous serving. Oh and the garlic rolls were great too. I was too full for salad so it’s for tomorrow too.
I ordered 3 pizzas and cheese sticks. Only received 2 pizzas and cheese sticks. When I spoke to Anthony's Pizza they blamed the dasher. Which could be true because the dasher didn't respond to my text. Ordered meat pizza added pineapples, mushrooms and jalapeños. Only 3 slices had the mushrooms and pineapple. And only 2 slices had ham. Ordered an pineapple pizza and only half the pizza had pineapple. The other half was cheese. 1st time ordering at Anthony's. Im disappointed. Food was good, but presentation not good.
First time there. I have a friend who loves it. We had bread sticks and Italian (calzones). I'm sorry I forgot what they called them. Food was very good but the lady who came out to rush us out the door was a little much. She was semi polite but she made it clear they wanted us to finish up and move on. She announced they closed at 9pm, but it was posted on the front door the hours were 10-10. ?
Book a table now
I've lived in morristown for 26 years and just tried this place today. Honestly, I'm pissed that it has taken me this long. Awesome new york style pizza. The cheese is creamy, the sauce is delicious, and the crust is great. The large pizza was HUGE. The chain pizza joints just can't compare. Will definitely be going here for our pizza nights in the future.
XLarge. Supreme mighty tasty ?! Love the crust not to thick !! For a supreme toppings were a little skimpy but pizza was really good! Garden salad was Excellent! Super fresh ! Good size for $6.50 ! 3 adults had left overs !
XLarge. Supreme mighty tasty ?! Love the crust not to thick !! For a supreme toppings were a little skimpy but pizza was really good! Garden salad was Excellent! Super fresh ! Good size for $6.50 ! 3 adults had left overs !
The service was horrible. No one there was welcoming at all. The pizza had no sauce and was very salty. The garlic knots were disgusting and hard. I will not be returning.
Book a table now
Just moved to Morristown. If you’re looking for a real New York style pizza this is the only place
Have tried a lot of pizza places since moving to Tennessee in November, this one is the best!
