I ordered a few things. The only thing that was good was the baked ravioli which was fine. I would recommend this. The fries were flimsy. Not crisp at all. Didn't even taste seasoned. The mozzarella in the mozzarella sticks was not fully melted. It also only comes with five mozzarella sticks which were each about the size of my thumb. They were half the size of what other mozzarella sticks are, they didn't taste good, and there's so few of them for the price. Lastly I ordered a grandma pie and their grandma pie is unlike any grandma pie I have ever seen or heard of. It was not good. Can't even tell if there is cheese on it. Definitely can't taste it. The sauce isn't sweet at all like a grand...
I wasn’t sure if something had been tampered with, but I expected an orange vodka sauce and instead received a light pink cream sauce that tasted terrible. I ended up with intense stomach pain, nausea, and the urge to vomit for hours. The side of meatballs I ordered did not look or taste like ground beef at all; instead, it was a big blob of undercooked, light tan meat that was unappetizing. It made me sick for hours, and I felt disrespected to have been served such a dish, especially considering the prices.
This raised serious food safety concerns for me. When I called to report the issue, the person on the other end didn’t seem to care that the food had made me sick, and it wasn’t due to...
Previous owners are gone, thank goodness. Pizza was oily, not sure they used real cheese. New owner Johnny makes a great pie. Unfortunately so far he has not been able to erase the bad reputation the previous owner gave it. I normally get a round pie with sausage. Not oily at all, cheese is creamy and real, sauce is good, crust is flavorful and cooked as you ask for it. If you ask for well done, that's what you get. I usually freeze left over slices and reheat in oven. Let people know we finally have a decent pizza place in Deer Park. 3/19 updated review. They changed owners again. Tasteless sauce., eggplant parm hero tasteless, bottom of hero soaking wet, top of hero stail. Very disappointe...
So my friends decided to buy the pizza from this place. Unfortunately, I felt so inclined to write a review. We tried a plain cheese pizza pie and ordered a few sodas with some garlic knots. I ate it and for the next few days my stomach was hurting. It felt like my stomach and intestines were having a world war in there. Horrible cramps that got worse with time. The only other thing I feel sorry for other then my intestines, was the toilet. It suffered a fate worse then death for those few days. Its so bad I think I gotta redo my entire my bathroom wall and plumbing.
Book a table now
Customer service is really good. We started going here about two years ago. The food was delicious. Now it's just ok. Don't know if new owners, cooks or what. I'm a vegetarian who loves potato and egg heroes. They had one of the best I ever tasted. Now, it's so so. The pasta with broccoli and garlic was also delicious, but now it's just ok
I visited Pizza Boss for the first time about four months ago, and ever since then, it’s become my go-to place for pizza whenever I'm in the area. I regret not discovering it sooner because their pizza is truly excellent. The prices are reasonable too, with a large pie costing just 14 dollars.
I called around to find a place that had beef patties, and it seemed like most places didn't. However, at Johnny Pizza, they had them! I ordered a plain pizza and a pepperoni pizza, and they were both delicious. I will definitely order from here again—great service!
Expensive and definitely not the best in long Island I feel they definitely over promote they're shifty food. But hey I guess the community preference is this low grade pizza spot do to the decor or something idk.
Book a table now
As soon as I got into NY had to order some pizza and Johnny's had good ratings on Grubhub. Excellent garlic knots and customer service.
The best pizza on Long Island!
Grilled Chicken Roast Pepper Fresh Mozzarella Hero
Chicken Cutlet Hero With Lettuce Tomato
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza
Chicken Pepperoni Parmigiana Hero
Chicken Fingers And French Fries
Sausage Peppers Parmigiana Hero
Sausage, Pepper And Onion Roll
Sausage, Peppers And Onion Pie
Chicken, Bacon And Ranch Pizza
Specialty Slice Lunch Special
