Honestly, one of the worst burgers I've ever eaten in my life.... We went for a band. Ordered beers and the first 2 were completely flat, but they tapped a new keg and made up for that so that is fine. The pretzel app was ok but they ran out of cheese and didn't tell us until the pretzel was already out. Wings were bland, slightly overcooked and half didnt even have sauce on them. The fried pickles were the only good item from the whole night. Fish and chips were basically tasteless and the fries were cold. The burger was ordered as super rare, but what was delivered was a bland beyond well done hockey puck with basically 1 slice of the little cherry tomatoes. I can without question say that...
Kitty Mulligans Irish Pub
615 E Main St, 11706, Bay Shore, US, United States Reservation"Great food, nice bar, friendly"
Details
Phone: +16313153571
Address: 615 E Main St, 11706, Bay Shore, US, United States
Reservation, Booking
City: Bay Shore
Opening hours
Monday: 11:00 -23:00
Tuesday: 11:00 -23:00
Wednesday: 11:00 -23:00
Thursday: 11:00 -23:00
Friday: 11:00 -01:00
Saturday: 08:00 -01:00
Sunday: 11:00 -23:00
Statistics
Dishes: 0
Categories: 5
Reviews: 51
Address
Reviews
I ordered a medium rare burger and it came out grey and overcooked..they RAN OUT OF PICKLES?!?! And didn’t inform us until I’d already gotten our food and had to ask. They appeared to be severely understaffed for the event we came for, which was to see a band play. We also had a reservation, yet when we arrived, there was nobody to tell us where to go or where our table was. We finally found it on our own after searching and found a table that was already there occupied with a family of 6 at the same table. Would not go again, unless it was for the band that played tonight.
Great food, great service, fun atmosphere. Burger was delicious. Cooked exactly the way I asked for. Drinks were great. Will definitely be back and often.Just read the other reviews, probably from the group of young guys that were so so rude and obnoxious. They most likely just left nasty reviews with no regard to the owners or staff that were working very hard.
The staff always goes above and beyond every time I go here. Whether I stop in for a drink or sit down for dinner with friends and family, we’re never disappointed! Food is great and the staff is even better! So friendly and really make sure you’re taken care of, ensuring you’re having a great time! Would definitely Book a table now
Saw the band revival there on Jan 13th. Band was awesome and drew a tremendous crowd in the place. The staff were awesome and handled the crowd great. Food and drinks were great too!!! Loved itParking: No trouble finding a spotWheelchair accessibility: Very handicap friendly place
We had an incredible Saturday night with DJ Ron spinning non-stop 80s dance hits. My friends and I had the time of our lives, laughing and dancing with Mel, the bartender. We’re definitely planning to return!
I brought along someone with high expectations from Babylon, but he was genuinely impressed with both the food and the atmosphere. The corned beef is exceptional. Sending hugs to everyone!
Great authentic Irish pub with amazing food and great entertainment! the bartenders and staff on pointI recommend this place to Book a table now
Great spot for enjoying live music and having some drinks. The pretzel was authentic and delicious!
Great food, nice bar, friendly
Book a table now
Categories
-
American
-
Burgers
-
Cheese
-
Pubs
-
Pub
Amenities
-
Delivery
- Reservation
The Penny Pub
79 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA, United States
Reservation, Breakfast, Salad, Lunch, Pubs, Pub
"Stopped in for a drink. Got some wings. Crowd is friendly staff is welcoming."
Bella Vie
240 W Main St, 11706, Bayshore, United States
Reservation, Bar-lounge, Italian, Brunch, Wine, Pub
"These guys are always consistent. Very friendly and attentive."
Yong Wang Kitchen
31 NY-27A, 31 W Main St, East Islip, NY 11730, USA, United States
Reservation, Seafood, Chinese, Chicken, Soup, Meat
"Been going here for 6 years since we moved here. We absolutely love"
H2O Seafood & Sushi - East Islip
166 W Main St East Islip, NY 11730, 11730-2298, United States
Reservation, Seafood, Chicken, Pizza, Sushi, Soup
"Great service. Delicious food. Music was a little loud"
Bruno's Pizza
1556 Brentwood Rd, 11706, Bay Shore, United States
Reservation, North American, American, Italian, Pizza, Lunch
"If you really want a good real pizza, please stop by Bruno’s"