Another problem we’ve encountered is the inconsistency of their pizzas. You might order a cheese pizza and find it amazing one time, only to be disappointed the next, as it doesn’t taste the same at all. Honestly, we’ve never received a pizza that was comparable to the previous one. It feels as though we’re ordering from two different restaurants. Recently, we ordered a cheese pizza with extra cheese and sausage on one half, specifically asking for a lighter crust since their pizzas tend to be overcooked. Unfortunately, this pizza did not meet our expectations; it seemed like the toppings were just carelessly thrown on, and it looked rather unappetizing. It was also undercooked, forcing my s...
My entire family got food poisoning. The following day, I end of speaking to someone who did not care or show any sign of empathy. His only response was Sorry about that . No offer of a fresh order or refund was offered. Very disappointed to what this place has turned into.Do not order from here especially on a Sunday night. I hope this saves a family from good poisoning. Order from Angela 's Pizza right on Islip Ave aka 111
Me and my family went there last week and it was so good the plain cheese pizza was delicious and the spicy mushroom,mix vegetables soup is my favorite from this place I love la casa pizzeria and I definitelyrecommendgoing there with friends and family!!Kid-friendliness: My kids loved the plain cheese pizza and the garlic breads!!
My Go To Pizza Place! Something about their sauce is so different from other pizza places in the area. They know how to season, for flavor, for sure. Their staff is so incredibly friendly and fun. When I'm waiting for my order, I enjoy talking to them. Keep it up guys!
Book a table now
The pizza there is so good Sicilian pizza is my favorite and is so delicious hopefully people that go there reading my review have a great experience. La casa has upgraded! Please try the soups it’s so good!
Pizza was delicious. The pinwheels and cheesy knots were very good too. Restaurant was clean and mostly organized. Staff was friendly and service was quick. Sufficient parking availableFood: 4/5
Unfortunately, they have permanently closed, which is a big disappointment because it had the best pizza in town. Food rating: 4/5.
This restaurant was incredible! The food was outstanding, and my family and I enjoyed every aspect of our experience.
Book a table now
Me and my family love la Casa pizzas it was a great experience I really recommend going there with family!!!
The food here is great, how come you guys aren’t on Uber Eats or Doordash anymore?
All Made With Fresh Mozzarella, Sliced Tomatoes & Red Roasted Peppers
Sausage, Peppers And Onions (Red Or White)
Bowties With Sausage And Fresh Mozzarella
Penne With Chicken And Artichoke Hearts
Bowtie With Sausage & Fresh Mozzarella
Penne With Sausage And Broccoli Rabe
Garlic Bread With Melted Mozzarella
Meatballs (3) Or Sausage (3)
Shrimp Scampi With Linguine
Seafood Fettuccini Alfredo
