I stopped by for a slice of pizza one evening, and it was fantastic. I saw they had a dinner special on Tuesdays, so tonight I picked up my dinner, which was perfectly packaged. The portion claims to feed four adults, but I believe it could easily serve more. I had the chicken parmesan, which was delicious, though I would have liked a bit more sauce on the pasta — but that’s just my personal preference, and I'll be sure to request extra next time. Everything was just right! The highlight was that everything was neatly packaged and ready for me when I arrived!
Apparently, this restaurant has been taken over by a new pizzeria, and I must say, they do not deserve their good Yelp ratings! I ordered a large pizza and mozzarella sticks, and two hours later, the delivery person called me to ask how to spell my address. When the pizza finally arrived, it was stiff and tasted terrible! I spent $30 for absolutely nothing. The only positive aspect was that I received a free Coke.
I visited Lexington Pizza just once, but their 'Fall' rosemary potato mozzarella pizza completely impressed me! It was so delicious that I can't wait for my next cheat day to go back and try some of their other offerings. The 'Winter' pizza, in particular, looks like a meat lover's dream—yum! They also offer gluten-free options, which are hard to find, so I'm definitely interested in checking that out as well.
The garlic knot meatball sliders were absolutely amazing—definitely a 10 out of 10! I want to extend a huge thank you to Mr. Brian Downing for his generous donation and for delivering these fantastic appetizers. Your support was essential in making our fundraising event for Gullotta House and Guiding Eyes for Autism a success. We’re looking forward to trying more items from the menu. Thanks again! Best, Matt
Book a table now
I've been stopping by this restaurant about once a week for a couple of Sicilian slices for several months now. The Sicilian pizza here is unique; it rises high and is incredibly light—absolutely delicious! During my last visit, I tried the Chicken Scarpariello slice, and wow, I think I've found a new favorite!
I've dined at this restaurant, enjoyed drinks at the bar, and ordered takeout. It's a fantastic local spot with delicious food and an excellent bar menu. It's a great place for groups or to sit at the bar and catch a game. The takeout and lunch options are outstanding too. The staff is incredibly friendly!
Now, about the Garlic Knots — I loved them! They weren't overly oily, making them fluffy and bursting with flavor. And my Meatball Parmesan on garlic bread was fantastic! Overall, this is a wonderful place. I would give it a 5/5!
Now THAT'S a slice! It was absolutely worth the drive over the Tappan Zee Bridge to give this place a try, especially since my favorite spot in Sleepy Hollow is closed on Sundays. I’ll definitely be back!
Book a table now
The pizza delivery from Epic was prompt, and the prices were quite reasonable. They even brought cups and plates with them when they noticed the address was a hotel!
I had a fantastic chicken parm dinner for four there tonight. The price was excellent. I highly recommend it and will definitely return!
