"We LOVE this place. Hands down our favorite pizza place! We drive 40 minutes one way just to get it. Perfectly cooked, crispy crust, fresh ingredients. They also have great chicken wings (we’re from Buffalo)."
Madison Avenue is simply the BEST! If you're in search of unique pizza options with an exceptional crust and a friendly staff, look no further! While you wait for your pizza to be made right in front of you, treat yourself to some delicious toasted ravioli. The Pickle pizza, Cuban pizza, Chick-fil-A pizza, and Italian sub are just a few of the amazing choices on the menu—truly spectacular! Keep an open mind; you’ll be pleasantly surprised at how well these combinations work! And I can't even begin to describe the Green Bean Casserole pizza—it's absolutely out of this world! The Stromboli is excellent too! My husband and I love trying the pizza specials; there’s never a dull moment!
I came here after hearing about their award from CL Best of the Bay, and I can definitely see why they received it. Although their flavors are a bit unique, the overall results were excellent. I tried the New York Supreme, which is my usual choice when sampling pizza, and it featured some delightful flavor accents. The crust was perfectly crunchy and had that lovely char that I always look for in a pie. While I'm not a fan of minced sausage, it worked fine in this dish. I also noticed that they are expanding next door and will soon double their size. I highly recommend Madison Avenue Pizza!
I visited Madison Avenue Pizza for the first time and absolutely loved it! I'm really impressed by the renovations and can't wait to stop by again. I returned tonight, 8/25/2022, and enjoyed the Chick Fil A special—fantastic! I could only manage to finish half. I heard the hype about this place and I'm glad to support it. I even took a picture with some of the employees, who were all so happy and humble in receiving our praise. Thank you, Madison Avenue Pizza! I look forward to exploring more of the menu.
Madison Avenue Pizza is an amazing place to explore unique flavors. As a picky eater, I was thrilled to discover a pizza I really enjoyed, called the Causeway. We stopped by after a day full of activities at the beach around 2 a.m., and the service was both prompt and attentive. The menu also features a great selection of local beers. The cheese garlic knots were equally impressive. Overall, it was a delightful experience for my taste buds!
Book a table now
This is a fantastic restaurant for trying out unique flavors. As someone who is very particular about my food, I was pleasantly surprised to find a pizza I really liked – the Causeway. We visited around 2 PM after spending the day at the beach, and the service was prompt and attentive. They also have a great selection of local beers. The cheese garlic knots were delicious and packed with flavor.
I must say, this restaurant serves incredible pizza! They even offer a 32-inch pizza challenge that you should definitely try if you’re up for it. The staff was extremely friendly and took the time to share their favorite menu items and explain the details of the challenge. The place was quite busy!
We absolutely love this place! It's our favorite pizza spot by far. We're even willing to drive 40 minutes just to enjoy it. The pizza is perfectly cooked with a crispy crust and fresh toppings. Their large chicken wings are a bonus, and as Buffalonians, we really appreciate that!
Wow, all I have to say about this place is the pizza was great. They have a 32-in pizza challenge. If you're feeling beastly you have to try it. Staff was very friendly, taking the time to explain what their favorite items are and more about the challenge. Place was packed out!
Book a table now
I always have a fantastic meal here. Sean and his team are truly creative geniuses! I tried the Mexican pizza tonight, and it was amazing! I can't wait for the expanded seating area; it’s no longer just a quiet little hole-in-the-wall spot.
We LOVE this place. Hands down our favorite pizza place! We drive 40 minutes one way just to get it. Perfectly cooked, crispy crust, fresh ingredients. They also have great chicken wings (we’re from Buffalo).
