We ordered a gift basket with cupcakes and cookies for a friend's 95th birthday in Massapequa, all the way from Brisbane, Australia. Having tried several bakeries in the New York area, we reached out to Mike, who quickly responded and assured us he could assist. After a follow-up call, he personally delivered a gorgeous basket. Mike made the whole process effortless, showing kindness and reliability every step of the way. Our friend loved the treats and truly appreciated them. Thank you, Mike, for bringing our idea to life!
About 2 weeks ago my sister purchased a chocolate cake covered with chocolate sprinkles. She brought it to my house.. The cake was so stale I could not believe they sold it to her. I was so embarrassed because I told her to go there.. They have some nerve selling a cake that old especially how expensive cakes are nowadays. Service: Take out Meal type: Other Price per person: $10–20 Food: 1
Mike accommodated a late evening delivery (after he was home from work, came back to pick up the cake to deliver it! without question, making my sister's birthday! The staff was so kind when I called in the evening asking if they could deliver a birthday cake that night. I could not imagine any other bakery going out of their way to help their customer the way Mike did. Thank you!!!!!
We ordered a tree log shaped cake, and Mike, the baker, truly excelled. When I first showed him the picture, he revealed that it was an award-winning design that can be quite challenging to execute. Nevertheless, I persuaded him to attempt it, and the outcome was remarkable—exactly like the photo! Thank you, Mike!
Book a table now
Need cookies? Fresh delicious cookies? This bakery is 10 star not 5 star. Their cakes, cookies, pastries are top notch. The owner is friendly and makes you want to stay and talk. In Farmingdale or near Farmingdale stop and partake of this bakery goodness. Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4
My boss retired after 43 yes of service, we had a small get together for him and ordered the cake from mike and the staff at Merritt bakery. Words can't describe how awesome this cake was. I would highly recommend mike and his staff at Merritt bakery to anyone.
Absolutely amazing! I ordered a custom special cake from Merritt Bakery, and it surpassed all my expectations. It was freshly baked and beautifully crafted. My nephew adored it, and honestly, we all enjoyed it tremendously. I highly recommend it to everyone!
Delicious gluten free cupcakes and chocolate chip cookies. They can make any cake gf, I am so excited. The best part is that they are not crazy expensive like a lot of other bakeries!
Book a table now
Merritt bakery makes the best cake and cookies. Pastries are amazing. I ordered an Elmo cake for kids birthday party. Everyone loved it and was all gone.
We ordered Merritts Bakery's Christmas cake. It was delicious and beautiful for a great price. Very recommended!
