The Pie At Salvatore's

The Pie At Salvatore's

120 E Main St, 11706, Bay Shore, United States Reservation
4.4 /5
3012 Reviews

"Great pizza... can't go wrong with their large Supreme Pie...very tasty."

Details

Phone: +16312061060

Address: 120 E Main St, 11706, Bay Shore, United States

Reservation, Booking

City: Bay Shore

Website: http://www.salvatorescoalfiredpizza.com/

Opening hours

Monday: 11:30-20:15

Wednesday: 11:30-20:15

Thursday: 11:30-20:15

Friday: 11:30-21:15

Saturday: 11:30-21:15

Sunday: 11:30-16:45

Statistics

Dishes: 10

Categories: 5

Reviews: 3012


Address

Show Map

Reviews

Tim

3/5

We were a large group, and were Sat quickly which was good, but the first course (garlic bread) did not come out for an additional 45 minutes, which is just too long for appetizers. There were 6 pies ordered, and they brought out one. That pie was gone long before the second and third pies came. There was one server working a table of 16, and would not entertain orders for drinks until all the pies were served. We have eaten here before, and have had a better experience, so maybe it was just an off night. The pizzas were just okay in my opinion, and not worth the wait. I hope they up their game moving forward.

Jack

5/5

Came here on a whim today. Was informed they do not do slices but indeed the small pie is about the size of a plate. Place looks older but is decorated tastefully. Ordered the neoploitan with mushrooms and in about 15 minutes it was on my table. The pie tasted wonderful. All fresh ingredients. The wait staff was real nice and will definitely be coming back

Mia

1/5

Was very disappointed with the service we received. Our waitress was not friendly at all and had a serious face the entire time we were there. She also aggressively slipped the check to us and immediately left, leaving us to wonder whether it was because of our race. Safe to say I will not be returning here.

Lori

5/5

It was my husband and I first time there and we absolutely loved the Supreme pie we ordered. We will definitely be regulars at Salvatore's. Can't wait to try more of their food everything looked delicious! Book a table now

Moonlight

3/5

Great atmosphere and friendly workers but the pizza definitely left a lot of be desired.. It was rather small and it looked and tasted like the base was just a flat bread.. Also on the pricy side.

Raymond

5/5

Consistently the BEST pie and food around.. They use Real mozzarella which is so good! Calzones the size of the box If you’re not happy with the food. I’ll pay for it! That’s how good it is

Alexea

4/5

Napoleon. I mean it was good yes, but did they take one piece of basil and tear it up? I was expecting a little more from such a nice place. I'll have to ask for extra toppings next time.

Joseph

4/5

I loved their sauce. I attended a private party. The room that the party was in was kind of cramped, the food was very good. This place is probably excellent for casual dining Book a table now

Keith

5/5

Excellent pizza. I got the original Neapolitan. Great dough and crust. Would highly recommend


Dishes

Side Of Meatballs With Mozzarella
Side Of Meatballs With Mozzarella

Broccoli Rabe Sausage (Medium)
Broccoli Rabe Sausage (Medium)

Tomato Grated Cheese (Medium)
Tomato Grated Cheese (Medium)

Meatball Hero With Mozzarella
Meatball Hero With Mozzarella

Rigatoni Filetto Di Pomodoro
Rigatoni Filetto Di Pomodoro

Tomato Grated Cheese (Small)
Tomato Grated Cheese (Small)

Tomato Grated Cheese (Large)
Tomato Grated Cheese (Large)

Caesar Salad Pie (Medium)
Caesar Salad Pie (Medium)

Antipasto Dinner (Small)
Antipasto Dinner (Small)

Antipasto Dinner (Large)
Antipasto Dinner (Large)