I 'm giving 2 stars for our server and that 's it and I 'm being generous but she was extremely polite and friendly and did her job absolutely correctly. We ended our vacation home to Ohio from myrtle beach to see the mothman museum and see point pleasant and wanted to eat at a local place instead of a chain or fast food. We picked this place due to their reviews. We walked in and there was nobody there and at least 5 employees standing there and nobody said anything to us. We had to approach the employees to seat ourselves. The food was not good. Frozen everything. My chicken parm came with noodles, frozen garlic bread and at best canned generic pasta sauce aka their signature homemade sauc...
We received a recommendation from the people at the Lowe’s Hotel and were not disappointed. All we had was very tasty, hot and freshly prepared. I had chicken parm and my wife had peppercakes. The chicken parm was just made with a very large part. Great taste and the right amount of spice. My wife said her paprika roles were perfect. Homemade. Overshading the excellent taste was the service. Our waitress was so nice, friendly and warm. Even the people who didn't wait for us were super pleasant and welcoming. A certain must.
Had a great experience here today! We're in town to see the Mothman exhibition and wanted to stop to try the Mothman pizza. Our waitress Lindsey was amazing and so courteous, she even brought the pizza uncut, so we could make a picture of it before she went back to the kitchen to cut it. Delicious pizza and amazing service! We are very pleased that she goes the extra mile to make our experience great.
I don't often get back to home to point pleasant. When I do I like to stop here and get a pizza. The quality is consistent I know what to expect when I go here. I think the memories from high school and in my youth are tied up someone in this place. I enjoy the new venue it is quite an upgrade from the old store. I will have to get over here more often do enjoy it.
Book a table now
This place is a Gem . The atmosphere was wonderful in its new location right next to the old one. Pizza was soft and had a golden crunch on the basis. The homemade pepper rolls were filled with cheese and pepperoni, for which you should die. And last but not least, frosted 22oz designs beers in a frost cup. 10/10 I will stand here again for a bite when I am over.
Drove about 7 hours with my best friend and Kiddo for a small birthday trip to the Mothman Museum and how could we not get into the Mothman Pizza?! I mean, really... it combines everything together and was a real good time.
Super friendly staff. Knew exactly what we wanted. We are mothman fans and they sat us down at table #8. Server was super friendly let us take a picture of our pizza before slicing it!!
Super friendly atmosphere. Amazing food. We drove all the way from Texas. Heard about this place on BuzzFeed unsolved and had to check it out and get the Mothman Pizza!
Book a table now
Add your pin to the map if you're travelling. They have a mothman table I you want something fun to look at while you eat.
An institution, and rightly so! We stop here anytime we are nearby.
