I really only bother to write reviews when a place is actually exceptional and Wendigo definitely fits the bill. What a surprise treat! We were heading to Brooklyn to watch a friend play music and needed dinner. Figured we'd just have to deal with random bar food, but then stumbled upon Wendigo. Online reviews were good, decided to check it out. Super cute, hip space without being pretentious, locally sourced seasonal menu with great tasting and good variety and portions, very reasonable prices for high quality, unique dishes. The place was hopping with Friday night dinner, but we were seated right away. Service fast and very friendly. We had the poutine, kale Cesar salad, and roast chicken...
Fortunately, our main server—who refrained from making any rude comments—was exceptionally kind and attentive. She genuinely enhanced our experience, but I left feeling a bit disheartened, especially since this was meant to be a celebratory occasion. As a former server, I recognize the pressures that come with busy shifts, but I would never have addressed a guest in such a manner.
The appetizers at Wendigo are truly one-of-a-kind and perfectly prepared! I sampled the fish fry, baked fish, fried tomato po'boy, Hey Hey dish, sweet potato fries, and mango carrot slaw—each dish was excellent. The cocktails were just as remarkable, and the star of the meal was the warm flourless chocolate cake accompanied by ice cream and chocolate syrup. Simply delightful!
Wendigo offers a fantastic atmosphere filled with captivating art and excellent craft cocktails featuring infused liquors. The menu is creative, though there are occasional minor execution flaws. Adding a guitarist and a pianist to the stage would elevate the experience to the next level. Definitely worth a visit.
Book a table now
Absolutely our favorite restaurant in Stoughton! The menu may be small, but the food is consistently amazing. The owner is a wonderful person who clearly cares about his business. I can't recommend it highly enough! Be sure to try the pickled and fried dishes!
The portions were generous, the food was fantastic, and the prices were very reasonable given how delicious everything was. We'll definitely be returning. Be sure to try the poutines or cheese curds—you won't be disappointed!
The finest cuisine in Madison can truly be found in Stoughton. The Wendigo consistently offers some of the most delectable dishes in the area. In my view, their short rib surpasses the one at Harvey House.
Such unique entrees, each executed to perfection! Even the cocktails were special, as was the flourless chocolate cake that was warmed and served with ice cream and chocolate syrup yum!
Book a table now
Awesomely quirky little place with poutine that is out of this world. Plus THE BEST sweet potato fries I have ever had! Popular at peak hours, so do make a reservation.
The BEST fish fry in Stoughton!! And Dennis is the best bartender.
