No trip home is complete without a bar pie and beer at Nellie's. Love it at Christmas...stuffed to the gills with diners, so it's a bit loud and might take a minute to get a table. But it's decked out in garland and holiday decor, everyone is happy, and the servers are working their butts off to keep the drinks flowing. For a true slice of North Jersey, you can't go wrong with Nellie's. I tried the Irish nachos, which were housemade chips smothered in corned beef, Sauer Kraut and mozzarella cheese. Great plate for sharing, esp over a few beers. Doesn't travel home as well. Eat it there. Order the extra pint. It's worth it!
This restaurant is well-known for its thin crust pizza, although the quality can be inconsistent on certain days. I'm particularly fond of their Elkin chicken wings, which have a unique spice rub that keeps me coming back for more. Some days I find myself craving them! The menu offers a great variety, and the food is both high-quality and flavorful, with generous portion sizes. Their soups are also excellent. It can get quite crowded at times, but the drink selection is impressive. We tend to visit about once a month and have noticed that the same familiar faces are often at the bar when we drop by. It's a true local gem!
I absolutely love the food at Nellie's. The service was decent tonight, although there are times when they seem to be understaffed. Fortunately, tonight was not one of those times. The outdoor seating area was lovely, but unfortunately, the only available spot for us was right in the sun, so we chose to move inside. Everything was great overall. The only downside was the acoustics; it can get quite loud in both the dining room and the bar at times.
As a self-proclaimed pizza enthusiast, my husband couldn't stop raving about the bar pie we had. In his words, it was the best he has ever had, and I can vouch for the fact that he has tried many different places. While the elkin wings were a famous menu item, I personally found them to be too salty due to soy sauce overload. However, I can see how they might be more enjoyable when paired with a refreshing, ice-cold beer. Cheers to that!
Book a table now
Their crust is outstanding! I had the veggie pie with bacon, no cheese : I'm sure the cheese brings it all together and makes it the famous pie it is. It had lots of fresh veggies, just needed more seasoning- again it's probably in the cheese I can't have. Even still it was delicious, fresh and perfect crust.
Best Pizza Around! The whole experience is enjoyable… the wait time, watching the hustle and bustle of the staff and seeing them manage their business that is bursting at the seams with loyal customers. Friendly, affordable and quality. Great job!
The pizza here is fantastic and it's a convenient meal option for the entire family. However, I believe they should remove the rugs, as it would give the restaurant a fresher atmosphere.
Vegans and Vegetarians beware. The dough is made with lard, pig fat. We confirmed this with an employee. Great place but I wish the Vegetarian pizza could be made without lard in it.
Book a table now
Excellent food, service was extraordinary...one of the best pubs I've ever been to!!
Very good, just wish the wings to go had blue cheese, ranch with the order.
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, And Roasted Pepper
Grilled Vegetable Fresh Mozzarella Wrap
Grilled Chicken Or Cheeseburger Club
Junior New York Strip Steak (10Oz.
Grilled Buffalo Chicken Salad
Quiche Of The Day Salad Bar
Mushroom Onion Swiss Burger
Rigatoni Plum Tomato Basil
Black Forest Steak (14Oz.
