I really enjoy the food and service when I go to New York Pizza! They have some great pizza with some unique toppings and their chicken tenders with their vast selection of sauces are excellent! The are always adding new sandwiches and items to the menu/specials to keep their guests happy satisfied! Their bar atmosphere is fun and their beer selection custom mixed drinks are also on point!I was raised in the Valley and grew up going to the different pizza places in Carbondale, I can say as a local that NY Pizza has been a great addition to the town! Also the service has always been on point with people you can tell really care about creating delicious food and have fun while offering great s...
Brad, or is it Chad) If your only way to insult a frequent patron is to call her a Karen then dude, you need some new material. That’s way 2021-22. Look into it.We respect the work you put into making your food and always tip to the best of our ability. It be great if you respected your hometown patrons the same way.
The pizza is fantastic, and the salads are even better. The hospitality here is top-notch, earning a solid five stars. I had a lovely casual dinner on the patio with my family, and the manager, Matthew, really went out of his way to ensure we had everything we needed. I’ll definitely be returning soon. Thank you!
The person who took my order was very rude. They messed up our hot wings and stacked all the pizza slices on top of each other. Plus, the slices were burnt, as you can see. As a local, I want to support local businesses, but this experience was disappointing. I won’t be returning.
Book a table now
The pizza is terrible—you can tell by the size of the tomato slices, which they don’t even bother to cut properly. It’s unbelievable. This is the worst pizza I’ve ever had. Everyone working there seems either stoned or drunk.
Outstanding customer service paired with an amazing atmosphere! The TVs make it a paradise for any sports enthusiast. The food and beer selection at New York Pizza Aspen is timeless and truly delicious!
On Tuesdays, they have karaoke hosted by Sandman. I ordered the Greek salad with grilled chicken, and it was enormous! It was incredibly fresh and delicious.
Tasty and delicious food all around. Pizza slices are huge and tasty. The chicken tenders are a classic and a go-to. Never disappoints.
Book a table now
Best chicken tenders in this valley, love the environment and the people are really nice there. Would recommend the Philly cheese
Pizza is great and all the ingredients are fresh! And their chicken tenders are the best in town!
